Skip to content
×

Can AI Replace a Social Media Manager?

At a glanceSwipe to explore

AI can write posts. Is that the whole job?

Social management includes routine publishing, interaction and brand judgment. Each level calls for a different role for AI.

A cat thinking through a question

Everyday posting is easier to delegate

AI can organize materials, draft copy and help with routine content. Use the time saved for higher-value work.

A cat working at a computer

Audience interaction depends on the mood

Humor, emotion and sensitive subjects depend on context. Someone who understands the brand should judge the response.

Cats discussing shared brand goals

Let AI analyze then use human judgment

People must define the brand’s position, voice and direction. The ability to generate text is not the same as sound judgment.

An illustration of moving from interaction to a purchase

Brand values take sustained work

Use AI to organize information and analyze performance. Keep goals and decisions with people, then select the tools.

An illustration of measuring channel performance

Most of us have considered using AI to run social accounts instead of hiring a social media manager. Many managers are probably already experimenting with it. Is it practical? Based on what AI can do today, my view is that entry-level work is feasible, advanced work still falls short, and expert-level work remains a long way off.

Three levels of social media management

We should not treat every social media role as the same. Different budgets and time commitments produce different kinds of accounts. I roughly divide the work into three levels:

  1. Entry level: everyday posts and maintaining an active presence. This describes many small and medium-sized brands. The main tasks are posting and replying, usually about the company’s products or services, with an occasional topical post. The goal is largely to show that the brand is still active; visibility itself may receive little attention.
  2. Advanced: audience interaction and activities. Goals are informed by data, and social media is used to introduce the brand to more people. Managers regularly interact with followers and organize activities such as giveaways, quizzes or meetups. This is the level at which many brands that take social media seriously operate.
  3. Expert: communicating brand values. Few managers reach this level. Building a brand’s identity and values through social media is not something a few posts can achieve. For these brands, posting is one way to express values that already exist. They can create trends, whether through a hashtag others adopt or a challenge. Their aim is for followers to embrace the brand’s values and willingly share them.

Where does AI stand today, and what might change?

Once we distinguish these levels, my position is straightforward: AI can already replace entry-level work, and in some respects do it better. It is not limited to service hours and can be available around the clock to prepare posts and replies. It can already write posts. If your only objective is to keep a brand’s social presence active, I think AI is sufficient without paying someone to do only that work.

At the advanced level, difficulties appear. AI may miss the humor and jokes between users. Its feel for the mood can be like someone who completely misses the point, disrupting an otherwise enjoyable reply thread. Routine responses can be delegated, but sensitive issues, humor and wordplay are more difficult. Do I think this will improve? Yes. But for now I would not trust AI to replace an advanced manager, especially when interacting with followers.

You can still use AI to collect data and analyze your audience. Those are useful ways to understand people better and improve how you interact with them.

As for the expert level, it is not only AI that struggles. Almost all social media managers struggle with it too—and I include myself. There is no need to jump that far ahead just yet.

Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp