Skip to content
×

How do topic clusters differ from other content structures?

A topic cluster uses internal links to connect a cornerstone page (also called a pillar page), which provides an overview, with multiple pages on subtopics. Compared with a content hub, the main differences are the emphasis on a cornerstone page and the range of content formats included. Compared with a silo structure, the difference is one of focus: topic clusters define each page’s role, while silos organize the site’s category hierarchy. However, definitions of these terms vary, so the name alone does not tell you whether one approach is better.

Content hubs: whether a cornerstone page is required depends on the definition

In a 2023 article, awoo notes that topic clusters and content hubs are broadly similar but can be distinguished when defined more narrowly. The comparison below follows that article’s framework, rather than official search engine requirements:

  • Topic clusters: Often used for article series, they require a cornerstone page that links to the subtopic pages, which also link back to it.
  • Content hubs: Broader in scope, they can include content databases, video libraries, and infographic libraries. They do not require a cornerstone page or links in both directions between it and the subtopic pages.

The two can also overlap. The English grammar overview page featured in the article introduces subtopics such as sentence structure, parts of speech, and tenses before directing readers to individual tutorials, which link back to the overview. It can therefore serve as both a content hub’s main page and a cornerstone page.

Silo structures: organizing categories rather than defining each page’s role

A silo structure emphasizes top-down categorization. For example, changing “Blog—Articles” to “Blog—Topic Subcategories—Articles” uses hierarchy and links to show how the site is organized. Topic clusters instead focus on how coverage is divided between the core topic and its subtopics, without necessarily adding category levels.

Whether links can cross categories is another difference. In the strict silo model described by awoo, pages in different categories do not link to one another. Topic clusters are more flexible: they can link to pages outside the cluster if doing so helps users find the information they need on the site. This restriction applies to the strict model, not to every website organized into categories.

Standalone articles or added links: plan each page’s role first

A topic cluster is not simply a matter of adding a few more links to existing articles. It starts by defining a core topic and then deciding which questions each page will answer. In a 2025 article, tenten uses mountaineering gear as an example: “The Complete Guide to Mountaineering Gear” serves as the pillar page, supported by content such as “Key Considerations When Choosing High-Altitude Mountaineering Boots” and “A Backpacking Checklist for a Three-Day Hike,” all connected through internal links.

At Procrustes, we also plan article topics around the questions clients genuinely care about, then continue to write and update the content.

Recommendations on how to link pages also differ. awoo cites TERAKEET’s criticism that HubSpot’s classic diagram places too much emphasis on links from cluster pages to the cornerstone page and does not adequately show links between related cluster pages. The recommendation is to connect related content, rather than only linking subpages back to an overview. When comparing structures, check whether pages have clearly defined roles and whether links meet readers’ needs, rather than treating a particular diagram as a guarantee of rankings.

Topic clusters and other content structures: perspectives from across the web

Does a topic cluster's cornerstone page have to be a long, encyclopedic article?

Not necessarily. A cornerstone page can be an encyclopedic article that covers the core topic in detail, or an overview page that introduces subtopics and directs readers to individual tutorials. What matters is that it explains the relationship between the main topic and its subtopics. The format should suit the content's needs, rather than being determined solely by length or the page's label.

When planning content around long-tail keywords, does each keyword need its own page?

Not necessarily. tenten recommends planning a pillar page around a core topic, then creating supporting content for related long-tail queries, rather than building a separate page for every long-tail keyword. Each page still needs to address search intent: comparison questions, for example, call for side-by-side comparisons, while troubleshooting questions require clear steps to resolve the issue.

Are topic clusters the only option for nonprofit organizations?

No. The Semrush article suggests that topic clusters may be particularly suitable for nonprofit organizations, but also recommends exploring other content hub models, such as content libraries and topic gateways. This is the source's recommendation, not a claim that every nonprofit should adopt the same structure. The material also does not provide enough detail to determine which approach is best under which circumstances.

References

  1. 長尾關鍵字與生成式 AI 搜索:掌握 SEO/ GEO 的未來策略tenten.co · 2025-07-20T04:28:41.000Z — Discusses: When planning content around long-tail keywords, does each keyword need its own page?
  2. SEO for Nonprofits: 7 Tips to Amplify Your Online Presencewww.semrush.com · 2020-11-30T14:30:00Z — Discusses: Are topic clusters the only option for nonprofit organizations?
  3. 10 分鐘理解主題集群 Topic Cluster:SEO 經營策略的另一種視角www.awoo.ai · 2023-08-21T10:42:03+00:00 — Discusses: Does a topic cluster's cornerstone page have to be a long, encyclopedic article?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp