Skip to content
×

How can you get and use writing feedback to revise an article?

To get writing feedback, you can ask a human editor or AI to identify what is engaging, boring, confusing, or hard to believe in specific passages and across the full draft. When revising, assess whether each comment is valid, then choose what to keep, cut, clarify, or strengthen. The point is not to accept every suggestion, but to identify problems worth addressing. An Animalz interview offers examples of this approach, but its descriptions of AI’s effectiveness reflect the interviewees’ experiences, not a guarantee of results for every article.

Replace a vague “Is this well written?” with four questions

In the Animalz interview, Nathan recommends the ABCD feedback method: asking a human editor or AI about four things. This moves feedback beyond whether someone likes the piece and helps pinpoint specific problems:

  • Engaging: Which parts are particularly good? When revising, first identify the material worth keeping.
  • Boring: Which parts cause readers to lose interest? Use this feedback to consider whether cuts or adjustments are needed.
  • Confusing: What is hard to understand? Revisit those passages to check whether the explanations are clear.
  • Unconvincing: Which claims might readers disagree with or find hard to accept? Check whether the supporting arguments are sufficient.

Nathan specifically notes that “unconvincing” applies not only to nonfiction but also to fiction. The question is not just whether something is right or wrong, but whether readers are willing to believe what the piece says.

Ask about passage details and clarity across the draft

The interview describes selecting text in Lex while drafting and asking for other historical examples, analogies, or metaphors. You can also ask whether the passage is accurate and which claims readers might disagree with. For the full draft, you can ask which parts are likely to be confusing. These are ways the interviewees describe using the tool, not assurances that its answers have been verified.

When reviewing feedback, identify the problem each comment points to, then decide how to revise. For example, if a passage is flagged as hard to understand, revisit it and make the explanation clearer. If a claim is unconvincing, examine the reasons supporting it rather than simply stating it more assertively. Historical examples suggested by AI should likewise be treated only as potential material, not accepted as facts merely because AI proposed them.

Choose valuable suggestions rather than trying to adopt them all

Nathan compares repeatedly seeking AI suggestions to digging: even if some suggestions are unhelpful, you may still find a worthwhile way to improve the draft. The interview also notes that a brief suggestion can sometimes have a significant impact on a draft. The number of suggestions therefore does not determine the quality of a revision; you still need to judge whether each one addresses the article’s problems.

Asking for tougher feedback does not necessarily make it better. Nathan says that adjusting prompts and asking AI to assess the author’s writing against a high standard helps reduce indiscriminate praise. Tim, however, says that Lex’s tough feedback is useful most of the time but can sometimes be difficult to take. How harsh feedback is and whether its suggestions are worth adopting should be considered separately.

Review interface copy in context

If you are revising interface copy, NN/g recommends that UX writers collaborate early with interface and product designers, ideally writing and revising directly in design tools. This helps usability tests focused on content produce useful feedback that reflects how people actually use the interface. This recommendation concerns UX writing; it should not be treated as a required process for every article.

Writing feedback: perspectives from across the web

How should you choose editing tools for feedback?

Start with the problem you need to address rather than treating every tool as providing the same kind of feedback. Semrush's editor recommends Grammarly for checking grammar and style, and Loom for giving writers detailed feedback. If the focus is search engine optimization, the editor recommends Content Optimizer for beginners. These are tool recommendations from that article's editor; their suitability still depends on your writing needs.

References

  1. Content Strategy vs. UX Writingwww.nngroup.com · 2024-07-12T17:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
  2. AI as a Personal Trainer for Writers: A Conversation with Nathan Baschez of Lexwww.animalz.co · 2025-03-04T00:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  3. 7 Content Editing Tools Recommended by Our Editorswww.semrush.com · 2023-09-04T15:06:00Z — Discusses: How should you choose editing tools for feedback?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp