Skip to content
×

How can you identify, diagnose, and improve underperforming content?

To improve underperforming content, first define what each page is meant to achieve, then use data to identify pages that need review, diagnose them individually, and decide whether to update, merge, or consider removing them. Bloggers can use Google Search Console (GSC) to find queries with high impressions but few clicks, then check the performance of the corresponding articles. However, a low click count is a starting point for investigation, not proof that content is poor or should be deleted. You also need to check whether the content matches search intent, whether information is outdated, whether there are technical issues, and what value the page already has.

Define your goals before deciding which articles need improvement

A content audit aims to determine whether content supports the website’s goals. If the goal is to increase organic search traffic, examine search impressions, clicks, and rankings. If conversions are the priority, assess conversion performance rather than judging success or failure by page views alone. Steadily declining rankings or very low impressions are reasons to investigate, not to remove a page automatically.

First, choose the types of pages to review, then use a spreadsheet to organize their URLs, goals, performance, issues, and next steps. Semrush’s product-page audit example excludes newly published product pages because they have not yet accumulated reliable data. That choice does not mean every article needs a fixed waiting period before it can be assessed.

Use GSC to find articles to review, keeping queries and pages distinct

Bloggers can start with a group of related topics rather than reviewing the entire site at once. In GSC, work through these steps:

  1. Filter for queries containing relevant topic terms.
  2. Sort impressions from highest to lowest to find queries with relatively high impressions but few clicks.
  3. Switch to page-level data to identify which articles need further investigation.

Data for a single query does not necessarily represent just one article; it may cover the search performance of multiple pages. To assess a particular article, examine that page’s data. GA4 engagement and conversion information can also help you understand what readers do after arriving on the site. Low engagement time may be related to loading speed or content that does not answer readers’ questions, but each possibility still needs to be checked.

Identify the problems instead of blaming everything on the writing

Noting each page’s issues is more useful for planning revisions than simply compiling a list of low-traffic articles. A single page may also have several problems.

  • Outdated or insufficient content: Statistics or information need updating, or the topic is not explained thoroughly enough.
  • Intent mismatch: Review search results for the primary keyword to assess whether the article meets searchers’ needs and whether it can offer unique insights or expert information.
  • Technical obstacles: Check for issues such as broken links and slow loading.
  • Overlapping content on the site: Similar queries across multiple articles are a signal worth investigating, but you still need to confirm whether those articles are actually competing with one another.

Match the action to the problem, preserving content that still has value

For articles with outdated information that still meet readers’ needs, start by updating research, data, or examples. Pages with insufficient content can be supplemented with expert interviews and appropriate images. If you confirm that articles are competing for the same keywords and undermining one another—a problem known as keyword cannibalization—consider merging similar articles while preserving valuable sections. Do not delete content simply because keywords overlap.

At Procrustes, our content service turns the questions clients genuinely care about into articles through ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

Check backlinks before removing a page so you do not overlook its existing value. Record a clear next step for each page: update it, merge it, or assess whether to remove it. After making changes, continue tracking performance against your original goals to determine whether further adjustments are needed.

Improving content performance: perspectives from across the web

Does an underperforming older article always need a complete rewrite?

Not necessarily. Backlinko suggests that some older articles need only minor optimization or improvements, such as updating information, adjusting images, or adding internal links, rather than a complete rewrite. A substantial rewrite may be worth considering if the article’s structure or angle is no longer suitable. Updating and republishing it may be more effective than writing a new article from scratch, but the results still need to be monitored.

If content performs well on social media but poorly in search, does that mean it has no value?

Not necessarily. Strong social sharing or overall traffic alongside low keyword rankings and estimated search traffic may indicate that the content resonates with readers but is not fulfilling its search potential. This gap can be a clue to reassess how the content is positioned for search. Figures from a single channel should not be used to dismiss its value.

Can outdated news articles be redirected to newer articles?

Yes, but first assess how closely related the old and new content is. Ahrefs gives an example in which some outdated car news articles were redirected to reviews of the relevant models after their launch. The author argues that this passes link equity to the reviews and directs readers to newer content that matches search intent. This is a specific case, not a recommendation to redirect every old article to a newer page.

What should you do when large volumes of AI-generated or template-based articles underperform?

First, review each page to determine whether it offers unique value unavailable elsewhere, rather than deciding whether to keep it solely on the basis of how it was produced. The Search Engine Journal author suggests considering substantial editing, trimming, or consolidation for underperforming content of this kind; large-scale removal is a more aggressive option. This is the author’s opinion based on observations, not a current platform rule.

References

  1. The Complete SEO Checklistbacklinko.com · 2016-07-26T12:35:01-05:00 — Discusses: Does an underperforming older article always need a complete rewrite?
  2. 關鍵字蠶食What does it mean?搞懂關鍵字蠶食影響,修復法一次看welly.tw · 2022-10-18T02:34:03.521Z — Source used in the article above.
  3. Content Strategy 101www.nngroup.com · 2022-11-13T17:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
  4. An Aggregator With Integrator Strategy – Carwow SEO Case Studyahrefs.com · 2023-02-21T05:10:33+00:00 — Discusses: Can outdated news articles be redirected to newer articles?
  5. Prediction: The Next Massive Google Update Is Around The Cornerwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-07T17:30:46+00:00 — Discusses: What should you do when large volumes of AI-generated or template-based articles underperform?
  6. Content Pruning: A Step-by-Step Guide to Improving Your SEOwww.semrush.com · 2024-05-09T09:05:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  7. Website Redesign SEO Checklist: Tips to Avoid Big Drops in Your Rankingsneilpatel.com · 2022-02-18T17:01:54+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  8. 5 步驟掌握競爭對手 SEO 優勢,提升Website排名tenten.co · 2019-01-11T00:00:00.000Z — Discusses: If content performs well on social media but poorly in search, does that mean it has no value?
  9. 8 Keyword Research Tools to Try (Free & Paid)www.semrush.com · 2022-12-22T13:52:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  10. 11 Advanced SEO Strategies for Organic Successneilpatel.com · 2024-12-17T18:12:14+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  11. Keyword Traffic Analysis: How to Boost SEO Resultswww.semrush.com · 2024-05-27T15:23:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  12. What is a content audit?www.semrush.com · 2025-01-10T10:39:00Z — Source used in the article above.
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp