Skip to content
×

How do you write an in-depth listicle?

An in-depth listicle is not about listing more items. It helps readers understand why each item deserves inclusion, what evidence supports that choice, and which needs it suits. Start by deciding whether readers want to explore options or make a choice. Then compare the same aspects of each option, using verifiable information and explaining your selection methods. The number of items and a tidy layout help organize the content, but they cannot replace substantive analysis.

First, decide what question the list should help readers answer

Animalz’s writing guide distinguishes between two needs: roundup articles answer “What options are available?” while comparison articles answer “Which of these two or three should I choose?” This difference should shape the organization of the content, not just the wording of the headline.

  • When readers are still exploring, focus on introducing the available options and the situations each suits.
  • When readers have narrowed their options, focus on comparing differences and providing a basis for deciding what to buy or adopt.

For example, a software selection guide should not simply list product names and brief descriptions. If it aims to help readers decide which software to use, it should cover features, pros and cons, pricing, and intended users so readers can compare the options.

At Procrustes, our content services also involve planning, writing, and updating articles around the questions our clients genuinely care about.

Address the same questions for each item instead of repeating praise

Animalz recommends using list items as subheadings, following a consistent structure for each item, and ensuring that the number promised in the headline matches the actual number of items. For a software listicle, answer these questions for each option:

  • Features: What can it do?
  • Pros and cons: What are its strengths and limitations?
  • Pricing: What cost information matters when comparing options?
  • Intended users: Which needs does it suit?

In its study sample, Seer Interactive also observed that listicles with growing citation counts used clear numbered formats and often covered the aspects listed above. This is an organizational approach worth considering, not a guarantee that adopting the format will earn citations.

Support recommendations with verifiable evidence

If an article claims that an option is the best, it needs to explain how the ranking was determined. Seer Interactive’s sample comparison found that listicles with greater citation growth during the study period often supported their judgments with external data or detailed evaluation methods, such as third-party ratings, government data, and publicly disclosed survey methods.

When writing a ranked list, explain the basis for the evaluation rather than offering only conclusions such as “powerful features” or “highly recommended.” The study cited Life Story Research’s building-material rankings, which disclosed the survey sample and ranking methodology. Letting readers examine the basis for a judgment helps them understand when a recommendation applies.

Choose the number of items for completeness, not a catchy number

In Seer Interactive’s study sample, listicles with growing citation counts often included ten to twenty options, while those with declining citation counts often had five to eight and offered less substantive comparisons. However, these observations came from a specific study period and do not establish that adding items will lead to more citations.

Rather than aiming for a particular number of items, consider the question the study proposes: What information does this article provide that similar pages do not? When adding items, include comparisons and reasons for selecting them. Simply listing more names does not mean you have covered those items in greater depth.

Listicles: perspectives from across the web

Is it still worth writing a listicle if others already cover the same topic?

Yes, but first identify questions that existing articles have not adequately answered, rather than simply rearranging a different set of items. Neil Patel recommends consulting listicles on the same topic and aiming to write a better one; Seer Interactive suggests checking what unique information the article offers that similar pages lack. If it can only repeat existing content, the new article will have a harder time adding value.

Do listicles need to be updated after publication?

Lists comparing products or brands are worth reviewing regularly, especially when prices, features, or pros and cons may change. In a sample covering a specific period, Seer Interactive observed that pages with citation growth were often kept up to date. However, in one case it examined, citations still declined at one point despite the page having a methodology and topical authority. Updating is a content maintenance practice, not a guarantee of citation growth.

How can you write a listicle headline without resorting to clickbait?

The headline should tell readers what specific content the article will provide, rather than relying solely on exaggerated wording to attract clicks. There is also no need to pile on repetitive words or keywords. In his advice on news headlines, Neil Patel recommends that list-style headlines offer specific insights and avoid clickbait. This can serve as general writing guidance for listicles, rather than a platform publishing rule.

References

  1. The 7 Most Common Blog Content Archetypes (and Exactly What They Should Look Like)www.animalz.co · 2026-03-12T00:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  2. How to Increase Your Search Traffic Without Building Linksneilpatel.com · 2015-03-03T16:00:53+00:00 — Discusses: Is it still worth writing a listicle if others already cover the same topic?
  3. Google Is Not Going to Stop Ranking Your Claude-Assisted Contentwww.seerinteractive.com · 2026-09-04T14:24:31-05:00 — Discusses: Do listicles need to be updated after publication?
  4. The Listicle Window Is Closing in AI Search: 30% Decline MoMwww.seerinteractive.com · 2026-02-25T12:06:36-05:00 — Discusses: Is it still worth writing a listicle if others already cover the same topic?; Do listicles need to be updated after publication?
  5. 5 Actionable Tips to Get Your Website Added to Google Newsneilpatel.com · 2021-07-09T15:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: How can you write a listicle headline without resorting to clickbait?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp