How Can You Weigh the Costs and Benefits of Reading?
When judging whether something is worth reading, the key is not how long it is or how much information it contains, but how much time you spend to gain useful information or enjoyment. You can treat reading time as a cost, then assess what you gain according to your purpose: does it help with purchasing decisions, save money, or provide reading pleasure? In a 2007 article, Jakob Nielsen used an information foraging model to explain this trade-off. The model helps us compare reading choices; it does not set a fixed standard for all readers.
Start with time—and include the time spent choosing what to read
You can start measuring reading costs by looking at the time spent. If two articles address the same issue but one gets to the point quickly while the other takes a long time to read, they cost the reader different amounts of time. But a quicker read is not necessarily more worthwhile; you also need to compare what you gain.
Nielsen distinguished between two situations: when employees read intranet content during working hours, their time carries a direct personnel cost; readers of public websites still care about wasting time, even if they are not paid to read. Reading costs therefore do not all need to be converted into money. You can also compare the time spent directly.
Choosing the next article or deciding what kind of content to read also takes time. To compare the entire process of finding information, count not just the time spent reading the content itself, but also the time spent selecting it.
Benefits depend on your reading goals and need not always be expressed in money
Nielsen’s article uses hypothetical “benefit units” to represent what readers gain, but the value those units represent varies by context. Before making comparisons, clarify what you hope to gain from your reading:
- Business purchasing: Does the information help secure better terms or select a more suitable product?
- Buying airline tickets: The benefit of checking another website or a different departure time can be measured by the resulting savings on airfare.
- News and entertainment: The benefit may be reading pleasure, which may not have a suitable monetary equivalent.
The amount of information alone therefore does not measure its benefit. For someone comparing prices, additional information is valuable if it helps them make better purchasing choices. For a leisure reader, the enjoyment of reading can itself be a benefit.
Compare what you gain per unit of time, not just article length
The information foraging model focuses on the ratio of benefits to costs. When reading time is used as the cost, the question becomes: For each unit of time spent reading, how much do you gain toward your goal? A long article may provide more information, but if it takes too long to read, readers may leave for shorter, easier-to-read content elsewhere.
This does not mean short articles always win. In the same article, Nielsen also noted that readers who need to solve a problem may require comprehensive content. When comparing long and short articles, consider both how much more time you spend and how much more you gain. Do not assume that a longer article is a waste of time or that more information automatically makes it worthwhile.
The precise figures used in Nielsen’s calculations are merely assumptions in the model, not universal thresholds. To apply the model to your own reading, base the comparison on the actual material and your reading goals rather than copying the example values.
The costs and benefits of reading: perspectives from across the web
If something is difficult to read, does that mean it is not worth reading?
Not necessarily. Asking someone who was not involved in producing the content to read it is an informal quality check. If they struggle, that may suggest the content is not good enough, but it does not mean the content has no value for any reader. To decide whether to keep reading, consider whether it offers the information or enjoyment you are looking for and how much time and effort it takes to gain those benefits.
References
- Long vs. Short Articles as Content Strategywww.nngroup.com · 2007-11-12T06:00:00+0000 — Discusses: If something is difficult to read, does that mean it is not worth reading?
- The 4-Layer AI Ops Playbook: From Better AI Outputs To Strong SEO Resultswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-16T19:04:30+00:00 — Discusses: If something is difficult to read, does that mean it is not worth reading?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.