When Should You Keep Competing for a Keyword, Change Direction, or Move On?
Whether to keep competing for a keyword should depend on its importance to the business, its conversion potential, and the resources available—not just its ranking. If a keyword directly supports a product or service and there is at least one viable route through organic search or advertising, continuing to compete can make sense. If it is valuable but currently too difficult to compete for, consider targeting more specific terms or changing channels. If it is not essential to your goals, the investment is too high relative to the return, and relevant, less competitive alternatives exist, you can skip it for now. A decline in traffic alone is not enough to decide whether to continue or move on.
Keep Competing: You Need Both Business Value and Resources
Semrush’s advice goes beyond simply pursuing important keywords: you also need to consider whether your website or content can compete. Even if a keyword is closely related to a product, check whether you already have strong content and authority, or the resources to build them over time. If you choose advertising, you need a budget sufficient to compete.
- Does this term directly support a product or service, rather than merely appearing popular?
- Could it bring traffic that converts into sales?
- Is there at least one feasible approach through organic or paid search?
Continued investment also requires goals. One answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange recommends setting traffic goals for specific terms and monitoring rankings. Once those goals are met, set new goals for broader terms. This is advice for gradually expanding the range of terms you compete for, not an official search engine rule.
Change Direction: A Valuable Keyword May Need a Different Approach
When a keyword is valuable but currently too competitive, changing direction does not mean dismissing its value. You can start with more specific, less competitive variations, or build topical authority before tackling harder terms. More specific keywords are generally less competitive, but that does not mean every long-tail keyword is easy to compete for.
Semrush uses “best travel backpack for men” as an example: if the term directly supports a product, it may still be worth competing for, but doing so requires outstanding content or a sufficient advertising budget. You could also evaluate the more specific “best business travel backpack for men” rather than simply investing more in the original term.
Competition in organic search and advertising should also be assessed separately. If competing through SEO is difficult, advertising will not necessarily be just as difficult. Organic search may also be easier while advertising is highly competitive. Switching channels is worth evaluating, but it does not guarantee lower costs.
Skip It for Now: Low Priority and High Costs Matter More Than Falling Rankings
If a keyword is not a core target, its expected return does not justify the investment, and relevant, less competitive terms are available, you can shift resources to other opportunities. There is no need to keep pursuing a keyword simply because you have already invested in it, especially when competition is tough in both organic search and advertising. “Skipping it for now” need not mean abandoning it permanently.
But do not treat declining traffic as an automatic signal to pull back. In a comparison of SaaS website traffic from August 2023 to August 2024, Ahrefs explicitly cautions that its organic traffic figures are estimates and may not reflect actual traffic. Businesses may also have reasons to remove pages and sacrifice some keyword rankings. The point is to interpret the numbers carefully, not to treat a particular website’s traffic decline as proof of a successful strategy.
Keyword competition: perspectives from across the web
If both organic search and advertising are highly competitive, should you give up?
Not necessarily. It still depends on whether the keyword directly supports a product or service. According to Semrush, important terms may still be worth investing in even when both channels are highly competitive, but they require outstanding content or a sufficient advertising budget. If a term is not a core target, the investment is too high relative to the return, and relevant, less competitive alternatives exist, you can skip it for now.
After targeting more specific terms first, when should you tackle broader ones?
You can tackle broader terms once the more specific ones meet your traffic goals. One answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange recommends setting traffic goals for specific terms and monitoring rankings, then setting new goals for broader terms once the initial goals are met. Repeat this process to gradually expand the range of terms you compete for. This approach suits those willing to invest in stages; it is not an official rule that must be followed.
Does a decline in estimated organic traffic mean abandoning a keyword was the wrong decision?
You cannot draw that conclusion from this figure alone. In one comparison, Ahrefs cautions that organic traffic figures are estimates and may not reflect a website’s actual traffic. Businesses may also remove pages for their own reasons, sacrificing some keyword rankings. A decline alone therefore proves neither that the decision was wrong nor that the strategy succeeded.
References
- How Do Search Engines Rank Combined Keywords?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: After targeting more specific terms first, when should you tackle broader ones?
- The 25 Biggest Traffic Losers in SaaS in 2024ahrefs.com · 2024-09-09T14:46:27+00:00 — Discusses: Does a decline in estimated organic traffic mean abandoning a keyword was the wrong decision?
- A Guide to Keyword Competition in SEO & PPC [2025 Data]www.semrush.com · 2024-10-07T09:34:00Z — Discusses: If both organic search and advertising are highly competitive, should you give up?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.