Skip to content
×

Under what circumstances might backlinks affect rankings?

Backlinks may affect rankings, but acquiring a link or having a page indexed does not mean rankings will change. Several factors are worth examining: whether the link is relevant to the content, whether search engines consider it for rankings, and whether link signals are consolidated into the designated URL. However, the sources discussed here are mainly industry articles and forum opinions. These views offer no formula for higher rankings and cannot establish how many links are needed or how long results will take.

Relevance and quality deserve more attention than simply accumulating links

Participants on Warrior Forum argue for prioritizing high-quality links relevant to a niche rather than large numbers of low-quality links. Another discussion goes further, suggesting that relevance should be judged by the linked page’s content, not just the website’s topic. The distinction is:

  • Website level: Do the linking and destination websites cover similar subjects?
  • Page level: Is the content containing the link relevant to the page it points to?

For example, just because two websites cover travel does not mean that any given article on them is relevant to the page a link points to. This example illustrates two ways to assess relevance; it is not the result of a ranking experiment. The discussions support the advice not to pursue quantity alone, but they do not establish that relevant links will necessarily improve rankings, let alone by how much.

Discovery, indexing, and being counted toward rankings are separate issues

A contributor on Webmasters Stack Exchange quotes older Google guidance stating that even if a link carries the nofollow attribute, the destination page may still be indexed through other links without nofollow or through a sitemap. Seeing a page in the index therefore does not establish that a particular backlink has passed ranking value.

Another answer on the same platform notes that Google announced in 2019 that it would treat nofollow as a hint and might count such links toward rankings in some circumstances. That answer describes a past policy change. It does not mean that every nofollow link is effective, nor does it establish exactly how these links are handled today.

Beyond how a link is handled, it also matters which URL receives the consolidated signals. An older answer suggests that, in other circumstances, a canonical tag may consolidate backlink signals into a designated URL and help that page rank. However, it explicitly states that adding a self-referencing canonical tag alone cannot improve rankings. The answer reflects an understanding of signal transfer at the time and should not be treated as a technical guarantee today.

Waiting longer does not guarantee better rankings

A Warrior Forum participant suggests a wait of roughly ten weeks based on personal experience. However, the original post uses both “average” and “maximum waiting time” without providing a verifiable statistical method. Ten weeks therefore cannot be treated as a general timeframe, much less as a guarantee that rankings will rise once that time has passed.

Link acquisition, page indexing, and ranking changes should be recorded separately. Even if a link is acquired before rankings improve, that sequence alone does not establish causation. The more cautious conclusion is that relevance, link handling, and URL consolidation are worth examining, but none guarantees improved rankings.

How backlinks affect rankings: perspectives from across the web

Can spammy links built by competitors cause a website’s rankings to drop?

A ranking drop alone is not enough to conclude that a competitor’s spammy links caused it. A Semrush article argues that search engines are increasingly able to identify and ignore negative SEO attacks, making such attacks often ineffective. However, the article also notes that some marketers believe these attacks can harm rankings and reputation. Unusual changes are still worth investigating, but links should not be presumed to be the cause.

Does the rate of ongoing link acquisition affect rankings?

These discussions do not establish whether it does. One participant suggests that the rate at which a page acquires links, and whether it continues to acquire them, may affect rankings. However, they provide no verification or indication of what rate might make a difference. This does not support the conclusion that faster link growth is always better, or that gaining links at a steady rate guarantees higher rankings.

If a link has no confirmed ranking benefit, can it still offer other value?

It may. An industry article notes that nofollow links can still bring traffic or brand exposure, while another discussion participant suggests that seeking links can help reach new audiences. These benefits are distinct from search rankings. Whether a link actually brings visitors or exposure cannot be determined merely from its existence.

References

  1. Ratio of No-follow & Do-follow Backlinkswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. Multisites Network SEO::Can self-referencing canonical tag(rel="canonical") inside article improve google rating?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  3. Nofollow Link (rel=nofollow) 完整指南tenten.co · 2025-06-04T17:01:26.000Z — Discusses: If a link has no confirmed ranking benefit, can it still offer other value?
  4. Negative SEO: What It Is & How to Prevent Attackswww.semrush.com · 2020-08-20T14:00:00Z — Discusses: Can spammy links built by competitors cause a website’s rankings to drop?
  5. Why my website is not ranking when I'm doing link-building since June 2020?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  6. How long for Google to notice new backlinks?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  7. Is there value in creating additional backlinks when you're already first on Google?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Does the rate of ongoing link acquisition affect rankings?; If a link has no confirmed ranking benefit, can it still offer other value?
  8. Does rel="nofollow" link helps in SEOwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  9. Why my website is not ranking when I'm doing link-building since June 2020?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
  10. Why my website is not ranking when I'm doing link-building since June 2020?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp