Why do search volume estimates differ, and what are their limitations?
Differences in search volume estimates do not necessarily mean a tool has made a calculation error. Database coverage, whether low-volume queries are included, and the measurement period can all affect the results. Search volume measures the number of searches, not audience reach or website traffic. Comparisons should specify the tool, search platform, region, and period; comparing two numbers alone cannot establish which is more accurate.
Even for the same keywords, a discrepancy alone cannot show which estimate is more accurate
In an article dated 2023, Semrush compared average monthly search volumes over the preceding 12 months for 100 keywords. Keyword Planner’s estimates totaled 1,066,100, while Semrush’s totaled 277,140. This comparison involved a specific sample and does not mean that all keywords would show the same discrepancy.
Semrush describes its own data as “more accurate” in the article, but the supplied excerpt provides no actual total search count that can be independently checked. What can be established is that the two sets of estimates differ—not that the lower figure is necessarily more accurate. The article’s explanations of Keyword Planner’s displayed ranges and advertising spend also should not be treated as the platform’s current rules.
- First, confirm that the comparison covers the same keywords, region, platform, and months.
- Distinguish single-month figures from averages across multiple months to avoid comparing figures calculated on different bases.
- Identify data sources, and do not treat a tool provider’s assessment of its own product as independent verification.
Queries missing from a database may contribute to discrepancies
In a 2025 article, Ahrefs’ Patrick Stox cautioned against directly comparing Ahrefs’ annual search volume estimate with Google’s stated annual search total. He offered several possible explanations: an increase in anonymized queries, gaps in keyword databases, or search volume estimates that are too low. These are possible explanations for the discrepancy, not established causes.
The author also speculated that longer search queries might be accompanied by an increase in anonymized queries, but this does not mean that long queries are necessarily excluded from the counts. When interpreting tool figures, consider the possibility of incomplete data coverage rather than treating the sum of estimates in a database as all search activity.
Averages help assess demand but do not necessarily reflect current interest
In its 2020 analysis, Ahrefs explained that the 12-month average search volume it used generally captured seasonal changes but did not necessarily account for elections that do not occur every year. Breaking news and new search topics were not reflected in the figures immediately either. These were methodological limitations of that particular analysis and do not establish that all tools now update at the same rate.
When evaluating breaking news or election-related topics, do not rely on average monthly search volume alone to judge current demand. Semrush’s introduction to search volume also notes that topic selection requires considering search intent and ranking difficulty. Search volume can help identify potential demand, but it cannot establish on its own that a keyword is worth pursuing.
On presenting figures, Screaming Frog’s data analysis guidance is to avoid unnecessary decimal places when calculations include estimates. More digits do not make an estimate more reliable.
Search volume estimates: perspectives from across the web
Can traditional search volume and AI search volume simply be added together?
They should not be added together without first checking how they are defined and measured. Semrush's introduction distinguishes search volume estimates for AI platforms from traditional search volume, which concerns keyword searches on search engines such as Google and YouTube. When comparing demand across platforms, identify each platform and data source separately to avoid treating different types of estimates as the same metric.
Can search volume tell me how many people will see my content?
It cannot directly tell you how many people will see your content. Search volume estimates how many times a particular keyword is searched. Semrush suggests that if ads or organic content have a chance to appear in search results for that keyword, search volume can help assess their potential reach. Search volume alone also cannot tell you whether a keyword is worth targeting; search intent and ranking difficulty must be considered as well.
Do “never-before-seen searches” and “anonymized queries” represent the same percentage?
The two percentages should not be treated as equivalent. The Ahrefs article quotes Google as saying that 15% of searches have never been seen before. Separately, 46.08% of the queries in Search Console data analyzed by the author's team a few years earlier were anonymized. These figures describe different concepts and cover different sets of data. The latter is not the current proportion of all searches that are anonymized, either, so the two figures cannot be used interchangeably or added together.
References
- How to use Google Keyword Plannerwww.semrush.com · 2023-03-08T10:25:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Insights From 55.8M AI Overviews Across 590M Searches—A Study by Ahrefsahrefs.com · 2025-05-19T10:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Do “never-before-seen searches” and “anonymized queries” represent the same percentage?
- How to Turn Data into a Content Marketing Campaignwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2020-10-13T08:00:29+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- What Is Keyword Search Volume? + 5 Free Tools to Check Itwww.semrush.com · 2021-01-27T09:40:00Z — Discusses: Can traditional search volume and AI search volume simply be added together?; Can search volume tell me how many people will see my content?
- I Thought Google Was Biased, But The Data Shows They’re Notahrefs.com · 2020-11-05T16:20:43+00:00 — Source used in the article above.


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.