Skip to content
×

How should you use broad keywords with high search volume and low competition?

A phrase such as “why does the” is only the beginning of a question. Even if a tool reports high search volume and low competition, that alone is no reason to make it a primary keyword target. A better approach is to use it as a starting point for finding specific questions, then narrow them down based on the website’s subject matter, readers’ needs, and actual competition. Targeting these questions is worthwhile only if the website can answer them and attract visitors who fit its business goals. Attractive numbers alone do not make a keyword a good choice.

Low competition does not mean no competition for rankings

A relevant answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange directly questioned the “1% competition” figure mentioned in the discussion: even if few sites specifically target this short phrase, many may target complete questions containing it. The respondent argued that these pages could still compete for rankings because their content and inbound links contain the same phrase. This is an assessment of that particular situation, not proof that all tool metrics are unreliable.

A low competition score is therefore not enough to justify investing in a keyword. A keyword-selection article by 大文西 recommends cross-checking search volume, clicks, trends, and competition. A 2016 article by awoo also suggests reviewing competitors on the first page of search results and assessing whether your own website can compete with them. These are recommendations for evaluating keywords, not guarantees of search engine rankings.

Decide whom you want to attract before comparing search volume

The opening words of a question do not reveal what the reader actually wants to ask. The discussion above cautions that if a website lacks sufficient content to cover the relevant questions, visitors may leave without finding answers, and other websites may be less inclined to cite its content. That does not mean a high bounce rate necessarily results in a ranking penalty.

  • Is the topic relevant? Can the website genuinely answer the complete question, rather than merely include the same opening words?
  • Is the need clear? Expand the phrase into specific queries, then compare search volume and ranking difficulty. Semrush’s keyword-selection article notes that more specific long-tail queries are usually easier to rank for, but not always.
  • Is the traffic useful? If the goal is sales or leads, rankings alone cannot be the measure of success. Relevant advice on Warrior Forum also emphasizes that keywords must relate to the business to have a chance of generating useful traffic and business opportunities.

Turn questions into content; URL naming is optional

The discussion also offers an alternative suggestion: if a website already revolves around “why” questions, it could consider using the phrase in its domain name and organizing URL paths around specific questions, such as why the sun shines and how the moon affects tides. These are ideas for website naming and structure, not evidence that such naming will improve rankings.

In practice, the focus should remain on the complete question each page will answer. If the website can only provide content in one subject area, start with relevant, specific questions in that area that it can answer. There is no need to branch into other topics just because their questions share the same opening words. At Procrustes, we plan, write, and update articles around the questions clients genuinely care about.

The advice above favors choosing specific questions that people search for and the website can answer, rather than betting on the entire broad phrase.

Using broad keywords with high search volume and low competition: perspectives from across the web

Can search volumes from different regions be compared directly?

Not directly. When choosing keywords, first identify the target region, then examine local monthly search volume and competition. This is especially important for websites serving a specific region. Comparisons should also be made between similar types of phrases: search volumes may generally be lower in niche fields, so a low number alone does not make a keyword worthless.

Are related, more specific keywords still worth considering if their search volume is lower?

They are worth comparing; there is no need to pursue only the highest search volume. More specific long-tail queries are usually easier to rank for, but demand and difficulty should still be checked for each keyword. Forum advice suggests that when a keyword with a similar meaning is substantially more popular, the lower-volume keyword should generally not take priority. At the same time, relevance to the business and the ability to bring useful traffic matter more than rankings alone.

How should you prioritize optimization when you already have articles?

If the goal is to update existing content, start by reviewing articles that already bring in more traffic or those targeting keywords with high search volume and low difficulty, then give priority to evergreen topics. This is advice on allocating resources: high traffic to topical news articles may be a one-time benefit, while evergreen content may deliver more lasting value. Whether an update is worthwhile still depends on the individual article.

References

  1. website ranking issueswww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can search volumes from different regions be compared directly?
  2. 關鍵字行銷建議工具『天下無狗』運用篇之:什麼是好的關鍵字?www.awoo.ai · 2016-03-09T02:12:26+00:00 — Discusses: Can search volumes from different regions be compared directly?
  3. How to use low competition keywords with large search volume effectively?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  4. 在不產出 [新文章] 之下,透過重構舊文章來提升 SEO 的方法?ithelp.ithome.com.tw — Discusses: How should you prioritize optimization when you already have articles?
  5. SEOChoosing keywords?挑選技巧大公開!行銷公司都這麼做!www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2023-04-16T22:26:27+08:00 — Source used in the article above.
  6. How to use low competition keywords with large search volume effectively?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  7. How to use low competition keywords with large search volume effectively?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  8. How to rank my targeted keyword for my website?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Are related, more specific keywords still worth considering if their search volume is lower?
  9. How to Run a Successful SEO Campaign in 2025www.semrush.com · 2020-11-05T15:30:00Z — Discusses: Are related, more specific keywords still worth considering if their search volume is lower?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp