Skip to content
×

Should New Websites Target Popular or Niche Keywords? Look at Demand, Not Result Counts

When choosing keywords for a new website, first define the website’s focus, then compare search demand, competition, and commercial value for relevant terms. Do not choose between popular and niche keywords solely because Google shows millions of results, fewer than a hundred, or none at all. The available discussions do not establish that result counts can indicate search demand or ranking difficulty. Popular terms are worth considering, but you need to assess whether you have the resources to compete. Niche terms need not be ruled out either, but should not be chosen simply because they seem easier to rank for.

Distinguish Popular and Niche Keywords by Search Demand

This article uses “popular” and “niche” to describe keywords with relatively higher and lower search demand, not different numbers of search results. The available sources provide no universal monthly search volume threshold, so they offer no basis for setting a single cutoff across all industries.

A PTT discussion points out that some niche phrases receive almost no searches, so even a first-page ranking may offer little practical value. This does not mean all niche terms are useless. Rather, it is a reminder that rankings alone do not demonstrate success. For terms with zero results, the available discussions establish neither that they represent an opportunity nor that they have no demand.

Choose Relevant Terms, Then Compare Traffic and Sales Potential

An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange recommends that you generally decide what to sell or what to blog about first, then choose the keywords most closely related to that content. For example, if a website covers a particular type of canned fish, it should not optimize for a broad term such as “food” merely to gain wider exposure. This is a contributor’s keyword-selection advice, not an official search platform rule.

  • If the goal is to attract readers: Compare relevant candidate terms to see which can bring more traffic.
  • If the goal is to sell products: Compare not only traffic but also which terms lead to purchases, rather than simply choosing the most frequently searched terms.

At Procrustes, we turn the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.

A 2023 Semrush article suggests that improving search visibility for commercially oriented or popular keywords may generate more revenue than doing so for noncommercial or niche terms. This is only a possibility: it does not mean popular terms necessarily lead to sales or that niche terms have no commercial value.

Assess Competition for Popular Terms and Check Demand for Niche Terms

Another 2023 Semrush article notes that many valuable keywords are highly competitive. New or small websites may struggle to rank because competitors may have larger budgets, dedicated SEO teams, and specialized tools. When choosing keywords, you therefore need to consider the resources you can commit. This does not mean every popular term is hard to rank for or every niche term is easy.

Popular terms can be worth targeting if they fit your website’s content and offer traffic or sales potential, but do not overlook the resource gap between you and your competitors. If you choose niche terms, first confirm that they match your website’s content and that people search for them. “Relevant and in demand” is a better basis for choosing keywords than “few search results”; a number-one ranking is no substitute for traffic and purchases.

Keywords for new websites: perspectives from across the web

Does a blog have to choose between popular and niche topics?

Not necessarily. One contributor suggests that since a blog can publish multiple posts, it can cover both popular and less popular topics. Popular topics may show readers that the content keeps up with current events, while less popular topics may help it stand out. However, any effects on search rankings and traffic remain that contributor’s speculation, not guarantees. Whether to follow this advice still depends on whether the topics fit the website’s content.

How can you adjust keyword choices and content to try to rank sooner?

Forum suggestions include trying less popular keyword variants, adding different modifiers, and providing more in-depth content than competitors. Some contributors also suggest avoiding commercial keywords. These are approaches intended to help achieve rankings sooner, not promises of a particular timeframe or guaranteed rankings. When choosing less popular terms, you still need to check whether anyone searches for them, so that rankings offer practical value.

Can you skip keyword research as long as you write good articles?

The available discussions do not establish that writing good articles makes keyword research unnecessary. One contributor believes that keywords will appear naturally if you focus on writing good content. Another recommends defining the website’s focus first, then comparing how much traffic relevant terms could bring. Websites that aim to sell also need to consider whether those terms can lead to purchases. The first approach emphasizes content quality, while the second emphasizes choosing keywords that support the website’s goals. The discussions do not establish that either approach alone will necessarily be effective.

References

  1. Is it good to start a website with keyword very popular or not so popular?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can you skip keyword research as long as you write good articles?
  2. Ranking of Keywords for new websitewww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: How can you adjust keyword choices and content to try to rank sooner?
  3. [問題] seoAds行銷公司www.ptt.cc — Discusses: How can you adjust keyword choices and content to try to rank sooner?
  4. Is it good to start a website with keyword very popular or not so popular?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Does a blog have to choose between popular and niche topics?
  5. SEO Visibility: What It Is & How to Improve Itwww.semrush.com · 2023-11-13T12:59:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  6. 7 SEO Challenges (+ How to Overcome Them)www.semrush.com · 2023-12-12T09:48:00Z — Source used in the article above.
  7. Is it good to start a website with keyword very popular or not so popular?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Does a blog have to choose between popular and niche topics?; Can you skip keyword research as long as you write good articles?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp