Skip to content
×

Will the original article be outranked when popular websites target the same niche keyword?

The original article could be outranked, but a competing website’s greater popularity alone does not mean it will fall behind. To compare the articles, look at content detail, on-page search engine optimization (SEO), external links, and internal links. Still, the discussions below do not provide enough information to predict an individual article’s ranking. Even if there was initially only one article and traffic later increased, those facts alone do not establish that a new competitor will win or that the original article will retain its position.

Compare competing pages, not just website reputation

A reply in the Webmasters Stack Exchange discussion notes that it is difficult to judge the outcome without knowing the competing page. The respondent suggests that a page with better SEO or higher-quality external links pointing to it is more likely to outrank the original. This is a conditional assessment, not a ranking guarantee from a search engine or a rule that “popular websites always win.”

  • On-page SEO: Rather than looking only at whether a website is well known, compare how the actual competing pages are optimized.
  • External links: The reply discusses link quality; a website’s popularity is not direct evidence that the page has better links.
  • Internal links: The discussion also notes that linking pages together effectively may help rankings for low-search-volume terms.

Rankings for low-search-volume terms may shift easily, but the competition matters

The same discussion suggests that when very few websites are optimized for a niche term, the limited competition may allow substantial ranking changes. The reply even suggests that one or two high-quality links, or good internal linking, could help a page rank very highly, potentially even in first place.

This claim is limited to the situation described in the reply: low search volume and few competing websites. It should not be treated as a fixed formula. “Initially zero search volume” does not necessarily mean those conditions apply. In particular, once traffic has increased and competing articles have appeared, the available information is insufficient to confirm whether the original competitive conditions still hold.

Compare content detail and unique insights, not just word count

In a 2023 article, Semrush recommends that content intended to challenge high-performing competing articles should be equally detailed and offer unique insights. By comparing an in-depth guide with a short article, it illustrates how a short article may lack the details and specific explanations the topic requires. It does not set a universal word-count threshold.

At Procrustes, we turn the questions that matter to clients into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.

If a new competing article already covers the same topic in depth, check whether the original article skips important details and whether it offers insights the competitor does not. Being the first to write about a topic or having a longer article is no substitute for those comparisons. These checks can help clarify the differences between the articles, but even filling content gaps does not guarantee that the original article will not be outranked.

Competing for niche keyword rankings: perspectives from across the web

If there was initially no search volume but traffic later increased, can experience with low-search-volume terms still predict rankings?

You cannot directly use that experience to predict rankings. The Webmasters Stack Exchange discussion suggests that rankings may shift easily when search volume is low and few websites are optimized for the term. In the scenario described, however, traffic later increased and new articles appeared. The available information is insufficient to confirm whether those conditions still hold, so it cannot be used to predict how rankings will change.

If a competing article is longer, does the original article have to match its word count?

Not necessarily. Semrush’s 2023 advice focuses on whether content is sufficiently detailed and offers unique insights, rather than whether it reaches a fixed word count. If the competitor already covers the topic in depth, a short article may lack necessary details. The review should also consider whether readers are beginners or experts and what problems they face.

References

  1. If my pages is the only one ranking for a search term, and a new site starts to optimize for it, will they outrank me?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: If there was initially no search volume but traffic later increased, can experience with low-search-volume terms still predict rankings?
  2. SEO Content Brief Guide: Everything You Need to Knowwww.semrush.com · 2023-11-29T09:51:00Z — Discusses: If a competing article is longer, does the original article have to match its word count?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp