Skip to content
×

How do target audience characteristics relate to search result preferences?

Target audience characteristics may be associated with search result preferences, but first you need to define the audience and how preferences are assessed. A survey reported in 2004 found differences in how respondents judged the relevance of organic search results and paid ads when grouped by internet experience, usage frequency, education, and gender. However, this survey shows associations, not that these characteristics cause preferences. Its findings cannot be treated as general tendencies among today’s users.

Distinguish between “which results are more relevant” and “what content people want”

You can analyze an audience by grouping users according to characteristics such as years of internet use, how often they go online each day, and education level. You can also explore their search tasks and content needs. Before doing so, be clear about whether you want to understand preferences for result types or content needs:

  • Preferences for search result types: The iProspect survey reported by Search Engine Journal in 2004 asked respondents to select the more relevant results for sample queries, allowing a comparison of their judgments about organic search results and paid ads.
  • Content needs: A 2018 Semrush article recommended using interviews and short questionnaires to understand searchers’ goals, concerns, and how they want to interact with content.

Judging a result as more relevant does not mean someone will click it, make a purchase, or trust it over time. Likewise, knowing what content users want does not directly reveal whether they prefer ads or organic results.

What differences between groups did the historical survey show?

The following figures apply only to respondents in the survey reported in 2004; they do not represent the current search market:

  • Years of internet use: Among respondents who had used the internet for more than six years, four to six years, and less than three years, 63.2%, 60.6%, and 54%, respectively, considered organic results more relevant.
  • Internet usage frequency: More than 65% of those who went online at least four times a day considered organic results more relevant, compared with 56.3% of those who went online fewer than four times a day.
  • Education level: Among college graduates, 64.8% considered organic results more relevant, compared with 56.2% of those who were not college graduates.
  • Gender: For sample queries on Google, Yahoo!, AOL, and MSN at the time, 43.1% of female respondents and 34.6% of male respondents selected paid ads as the most relevant results.

These percentages reflect respondents’ choices within each group; they do not mean that everyone in a group shares the same preference. The supplied survey excerpts do not provide the sample size, sampling method, or statistical significance. They therefore cannot establish whether each characteristic was independently associated with preferences, rather than reflecting the influence of other characteristics.

Use search terms to understand needs rather than assume what audiences want

A 2023 article on Neil Patel’s website noted that keyword research can provide clues about an audience’s information needs. For example, a search for “HTML5 tutorial for beginners” may suggest that the searcher needs an introductory explanation. That clue is more closely tied to the particular query than an assumption based on education level alone, but it still does not establish a preference for organic results or ads.

At Procrustes, our content work turns the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

When analyzing a target audience, record group characteristics, search tasks, and preference measures separately. Historical surveys can provide clues to test, but understanding how a particular audience chooses search results today still requires current data from that audience.

Target audience characteristics and search result preferences: perspectives from across the web

Is employment status associated with judgments of search result relevance?

In the iProspect survey reported in 2004, nearly 65% of full-time employed respondents selected organic results as the most relevant for sample queries, compared with 60.8% of part-time employed respondents and 55.1% of respondents who were not employed. These were differences between groups in that survey. They do not establish that employment status causes preferences, nor can they be used to directly infer the choices of today's job seekers or other customer groups.

How can you understand what content a specific audience really needs?

Use interviews or short questionnaires to ask searchers about the tasks they want to accomplish, their concerns, the content they seek, and how they want to interact with it. Their answers can help you design experiences that meet respondents' needs. You still need to check whether those respondents adequately represent the target audience, and their content needs do not directly reveal a preference for ads or organic results.

Can keyword research replace asking the audience directly?

Not entirely. Keyword research can offer clues about what a target audience wants to know and what information it seeks, helping guide titles and relevant page content. Interviews can explore the motivations and concerns behind search tasks in greater depth. The two methods answer different questions; search terms alone are not enough to establish which type of result a searcher will choose.

References

  1. How To Identify Search Intent in Organic Results: A Complete Guidewww.semrush.com · 2018-09-13T07:00:00Z — Discusses: How can you understand what content a specific audience really needs?; Can keyword research replace asking the audience directly?
  2. How to Improve Your Google Rankings (Without Getting Penalized)neilpatel.com · 2023-05-19T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Can keyword research replace asking the audience directly?
  3. Study Shows Target Demographics Important in Search Engine Marketing Campaignswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2004-05-18T17:25:28+00:00 — Discusses: Is employment status associated with judgments of search result relevance?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp