What should you do when a page gets substantial traffic from keywords you did not target?
Do not change a page simply because it receives traffic from keywords you did not target, or add services just because traffic is high. A more cautious approach is to check whether the queries relate to the page’s goals and how the original target keywords are performing. Then decide whether to leave the page as it is, expand its content, or change direction. The available material includes both recommendations to retain the traffic and calls to revise the content; it does not support leaving every page untouched or rewriting them all.
Untargeted does not mean unrelated to your business
A 2025 Backlinko article notes that Google Search Console can reveal the queries people use to find a website, including terms the site has not deliberately targeted. These queries may reflect the interests of a relevant audience or raise questions worth answering separately. The first step is to examine the actual queries rather than immediately dismiss unexpected traffic as useless.
- Identify terms that already generate impressions and clicks but have no content planned for them, and assess whether they fit the page’s existing topic.
- Look for question-based queries and check whether the existing content answers them or a separate article is needed.
- Queries with few impressions are also worth monitoring. The article suggests they may represent emerging topics or specific needs, but does not guarantee future growth.
Before making changes, check rankings for your original target keywords
Warrior Forum contributor dave_hermansen focuses on one key question: how is the page performing for the terms you actually want to target? His advice is to revise some of the content if rankings for the target terms are poor. This is practical advice with a specific condition, not an official search engine rule. It should not be read as “unexpected keywords mean the page must be revamped.”
In the hypothetical scenario discussed, a website offering SEO and SMO services ranks in the top five for Folkd and receives a tenth of its traffic from that term. That alone is not enough to determine whether it should add other services. You would also need to know what visitors are searching for, what the page offers, and how the original target terms are performing. Traffic share alone does not answer these questions.
Forum participants also disagree: MikeFriedman recommends ignoring this traffic and continuing with other work, while Medon advocates repurposing the content. Neither provides enough detail to justify applying their advice to every website.
Related queries may call for more content; internal links depend on the circumstances
If the queries genuinely relate to the website’s subject matter, consider creating additional content rather than immediately repurposing the original page. A 2023 Semrush article recommends first checking which keywords a high-traffic blog post ranks for and which websites link to it. It then suggests creating content and topic clusters around the well-performing terms. Only in some cases is it appropriate to optimize existing pages for those terms.
At Procrustes, we turn the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.
Backlinks are another factor to check. Forum contributor Ecrease suggests adding internal links from a high-performing page to other pages whose rankings you want to improve, provided the high-performing page already has backlinks. He also advocates preserving its rankings because the page may attract links; this is a possibility, not a guarantee. His comments on how Google might use such pages when they have no backlinks are explicitly personal speculation and should not be used to promise ranking improvements.
Unexpected keyword traffic: perspectives from across the web
Does traffic from unrelated keywords necessarily harm SEO?
You should not conclude that SEO is being harmed simply because traffic comes from other keywords. One forum contributor believes this traffic does not hurt SEO, while another advises against worrying too much about completely unrelated terms and recommends continuing to optimize the page. These are practical opinions; they do not mean all traffic has business value, nor do they replace examining the actual queries and the page’s goals.
Does unrelated traffic increase the bounce rate, making content changes necessary?
Not necessarily. Unrelated traffic alone does not mean you must revise the content. One forum contributor suggests that the bounce rate may rise if visitors cannot find what they are looking for, and therefore recommends content changes. Another states outright that unrelated traffic increases the bounce rate. The first describes a possibility. The available material does not provide enough data to show that this traffic always increases the bounce rate, nor does it justify changing a page on that basis alone.
Can you monetize this traffic or add services to serve it?
These options are worth assessing, but you should not add services simply because traffic is high. Forum suggestions include offering the products or services visitors are looking for, directing them to other pages when relevant, or considering advertising and affiliate marketing programs related to the keywords. The contributor suggesting products and services also acknowledges that the best approach cannot be determined without specific details; suitability still depends on visitors’ needs and what the website actually offers.
References
- The Ultimate Guide to Casino SEO: How to Rank Higher, Fasterwww.semrush.com · 2023-12-27T13:16:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- 7 Ways to Find Related Content (+ Free Topic Planner)backlinko.com · 2025-06-23T09:48:01-05:00 — Source used in the article above.
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- Most of my traffic coming from an irrelevant keywordwww.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does traffic from unrelated keywords necessarily harm SEO?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does traffic from unrelated keywords necessarily harm SEO?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can you monetize this traffic or add services to serve it?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can you monetize this traffic or add services to serve it?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does unrelated traffic increase the bounce rate, making content changes necessary?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does unrelated traffic increase the bounce rate, making content changes necessary?
- What should be done if you rank high and attract traffic with irrelevant keyword?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Can you monetize this traffic or add services to serve it?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.