How should recipe websites choose search keywords and match them to content?
When choosing search keywords, recipe websites should first identify what each page actually offers, then decide which search needs it should meet: an individual recipe, a list of similar recipes, or nutritional information about ingredients and dishes. The Q&A advice summarized below focuses on choosing specific target terms and matching them to suitable pages, rather than having every page broadly target “food.” A site can keep its latest-recipe list and use tags to create index pages for specific topics. These are practical suggestions, however, not official search engine ranking rules.
First, identify whether searchers want a recipe or information about a dish
Two pages about tomato soup will not necessarily meet the same search needs. One response explains that relevance depends on the search term: for “tomato soup recipe,” a recipe page is more relevant than a nutrition page; for “tomato soup,” both may be relevant. When choosing keywords, look beyond whether a page mentions the dish and consider what kind of answer it provides.
- A page explaining how to make tomato soup suits readers looking for a tomato soup recipe.
- A page about tomato soup’s nutritional content provides information about the dish. It should not be treated as a recipe page simply because it uses the same dish name.
- Page titles should reflect the actual content, rather than force a chosen keyword onto content that does not match.
At Procrustes, our work includes planning pages for partner websites, as well as planning content topics, writing, and updating content.
Latest-recipe lists and topic indexes can serve different needs
Another response suggests continuing to update the homepage while adding topic pages organized by tags alongside the changing list of recent links. For example, a “chocolate cake” page could list only recipes with the corresponding tag. Readers looking for chocolate cake could then land on a relevant list rather than a latest-recipe list containing all kinds of dishes.
This turns “Is this good for SEO?” into a few more specific questions: Which search term are you targeting? Which page do you want readers to land on? Does that page actually bring together relevant recipes? The original response suggests that these topic indexes should perform better than the existing pages for the corresponding searches. But this was advice for the website in question, not a guarantee that creating tag pages will improve rankings.
Existing search visibility can guide content changes
A further response suggests identifying search terms for which the site already appears on the second or third page of Google results, then trying content that includes those terms and stays on the homepage. Unlike simply adding links to the latest recipes, the aim is to keep some homepage content from disappearing as the list is updated.
The respondent offered this advice after reviewing that particular website and said only that it “might” help the site reach the first page of search results. It can be a starting point for reviewing existing search performance, but it does not mean that all recipe websites should put target terms on their homepages or guarantee an increase in traffic. Whether content belongs on the homepage, a topic index, or an individual recipe page should still depend on how well the search term matches the page’s content.
Choosing keywords and matching content on recipe websites: perspectives from across the web
What should you ask first when evaluating a recipe website’s SEO?
Start with two questions: Which search term are you evaluating? Which page do you want searchers to land on? One response argues that if all pages broadly target “food,” it is difficult to tell which page should address a particular search. This is a diagnosis of the website in question, not a claim that every website using broad terms has the same problem.
Can different pages about the same dish be relevant to the same search term?
They can, depending on how specific the search term is. One response gives this example: both a recipe page and a nutrition page may be relevant to “tomato soup,” but the recipe page is more relevant to “tomato soup recipe.” So even when two pages cover the same dish, they are not necessarily equally relevant to every search term.
Is it worth adding terms to the homepage if the site already appears on the second or third page of results for them?
It may be worth testing, but not every website needs to do this. After reviewing the website in question, one respondent suggested identifying these terms and keeping content that includes them on the homepage. The respondent thought this might help the site reach the first page of search results and increase traffic. This case-specific advice is not a guarantee that it will work or a recommendation for every website to follow.
References
- 3 Scenarios for most relevant keywords in website. Which one is best?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Can different pages about the same dish be relevant to the same search term?
- Should page contents be same all time for SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: What should you ask first when evaluating a recipe website’s SEO?
- Should page contents be same all time for SEO?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is it worth adding terms to the homepage if the site already appears on the second or third page of results for them?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.