How does AI-generated content relate to search rankings, and how should it be used for SEO?
AI-generated content can appear near the top of search results, but the available material does not establish that using AI itself improves or lowers rankings. The correlations reported in the studies are inconsistent, and they do not directly reveal how Google treats individual pages. For SEO, a better-supported approach is to use AI for brainstorming and first drafts, then have people check the facts, edit the text, and add unique information. Mass-produced content should not be treated as a ranking guarantee.
What did the ranking studies find, and what can they not prove?
In a study published in 2025, Ahrefs analyzed 600,000 web pages drawn from the top 20 results for 100,000 random keywords. In this dataset, the correlation coefficient between the proportion of AI content and ranking position was 0.011, indicating almost no clear relationship. The authors interpreted this as suggesting that Google did not appear to significantly reward or penalize pages solely for using AI. That is an interpretation of the findings, not proof of causation.
Another Ahrefs study in 2026 sampled 15,000 pages at each ranking position and analyzed them using its AI content detection tool. The average proportion of AI content was 27.1% for pages in first place and 30.9% for those in tenth place; the medians were 17.1% and 19.5%, respectively. This shows that a higher proportion of content was detected as AI-generated on lower-ranking pages, but it does not mean AI caused rankings to drop.
The research also cautioned that looking only at URLs that already rank excludes pages that have not been indexed. In July 2026, Search Engine Journal quoted co-author Ryan Law as saying that the difference appeared to be related to declining content quality as AI use increased, rather than Google taking direct action based on how the content was generated. This remains an interpretation of the difference; a high AI detection score does not mean the content is poor or has been penalized.
AI is allowed, but not every way of using it is appropriate
A July 2026 Search Engine Journal article quoted Google’s guidance: using automation or AI is not inherently a violation, provided that its primary purpose is not to manipulate search rankings. This account is based on reporting from that period and does not guarantee that any website currently complies with the guidelines.
The same article listed problems such as producing large volumes of articles that merely restate existing search results without adding information, or translating content without adapting it to local currencies, culture, and search intent. When reviewing content, the focus should therefore be not just on “how much AI was used,” but also on whether it genuinely provides useful information.
Use AI to help create content, with human oversight
A 2023 article by awoo listed AI uses such as generating titles and descriptions, planning copy, and brainstorming frequently asked questions. It also warned that generated content can sound unnatural or contain factual inaccuracies. Following its editorial principles, the work can be divided into three steps:
- Define the needs first: Understand the topic and keywords before using AI to help with planning, rather than focusing solely on the number of articles produced.
- Treat the output as a draft: Check each fact and revise passages that are unclear or do not meet readers’ needs.
- Add unique information: Go beyond summarizing existing search results. For example, when creating content for different markets, check the local context and wording rather than reuse the same material unchanged.
At Procrustes, our content work turns the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.
AI-generated content and search rankings: perspectives from across the web
Does seeing AI content on the first page prove that Google favors it?
No. One forum participant believed Google had accepted AI content based on examples they had seen on the first page; another claimed that Google would not rank pages for keywords related to AI content. The former is merely a personal observation, while the latter's absolute claim is also inconsistent with research findings showing AI content among the top results. Individual examples can show that certain pages rank, but they cannot prove that the method of generation is the reason for those rankings.
Can scores from SEO content tools be treated as ranking guarantees?
Scores should not be treated as ranking guarantees. Semrush's Content Optimizer, for example, offers SEO, readability, and tone recommendations based on the goals set, while its overall score is used to track editing progress. It also provides information on competitors' titles, structure, and sources, which can help identify content gaps. However, users still need to assess whether the recommendations suit their target readers and whether the article offers unique information.
What unique information can be added to an AI-generated first draft?
Depending on the topic, additions can include real-world examples, original data from your own research or projects, well-supported expert insights, and client stories suitable for public sharing. These details can help a draft demonstrate the brand's expertise rather than merely repeat competitors' existing content. The information must genuinely exist and be verified; it must not be fabricated simply to make the article seem unique.
References
- ChatGPT x SEO 行銷人的 15 個 FAQ 大哉問www.awoo.ai · 2023-03-28T02:22:09+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Social Search Data For All, AI-Detected Pages Rank Lower – SEO Pulsewww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-07-31T12:30:09+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 7 Content Editing Tools Recommended by Our Editorswww.semrush.com · 2023-09-04T15:06:00Z — Discusses: Can scores from SEO content tools be treated as ranking guarantees?
- Google Doesn’t Punish AI Content; It Punishes Bad Content (331k Pages Studied)ahrefs.com · 2026-07-27T08:00:13+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- 9 Biggest SEO Trends of 2025 & How to Leverage Themwww.semrush.com · 2020-10-30T15:00:00Z — Discusses: What unique information can be added to an AI-generated first draft?
- keyword research improvement for articles? SEO, Davinci resolve editing vids and social media:www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does seeing AI content on the first page prove that Google favors it?
- What if Ai automated everything for SEO?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Does seeing AI content on the first page prove that Google favors it?
- AI-Generated Content Does Not Hurt Your Google Rankings (600,000 Pages Analyzed)ahrefs.com · 2025-07-07T10:00:19+00:00 — Discusses: Does seeing AI content on the first page prove that Google favors it?
- Why Scaled AI Content Fails: Google’s Crawl Economics Explainedwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-07-14T11:30:48+00:00 — Source used in the article above.


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.