Skip to content
×

How do you audit existing content and decide what to keep, improve, or remove?

Start by creating a content inventory, then assess whether each item still serves a purpose, is accurate, and can be improved. Keep content that still meets current needs and requires no corrections. Update content if the topic still matters but the information or presentation is outdated. Consider removal only when content is no longer relevant and offers little value even with improvements. Age, traffic, and rankings are signals to investigate; none should determine on its own what stays or goes.

Build an inventory before assessing quality

In its 2020 article on content inventories, NN/g explains that an inventory records “what content exists,” while an audit assesses “how good it is and what needs to be done.” Neither replaces the other; a list of URLs alone is not enough to decide which pages to delete.

  • Basic information: title, URL, format, creation date, author, and metadata.
  • What to assess: whether the content still meets current needs, whether its information is outdated, and how it performs in traffic, rankings, conversions, and backlinks.
  • What to do: keep as is, update or merge, or remove. Record the reasons for the decision.

Use data to identify problems, not to decide alone what stays or goes

Semrush’s 2024 article identifies significant ranking drops and declining traffic and conversions as signals to check whether content needs updating. It also notes that minor ranking fluctuations are normal. These changes warrant investigation, but they do not establish that outdated content caused the decline.

In its 2015 discussion of enterprise intranet migration, NN/g notes that low traffic may mean a page is hard to find, while high traffic does not necessarily mean users’ questions have been answered. A short visit may mean the information is useless, or it may mean an employee quickly found a phone number. This intranet example shows why metrics need to be interpreted alongside user goals and findings from interviews or testing.

Choose an action based on relevance and room for improvement

  • Keep: The content still meets current needs, is accurate, and answers users’ questions. There is no need to rewrite it just to say it has been updated.
  • Update: The topic still aligns with the brand and strategy, and the content can be significantly improved. Prioritize assessing older articles that still attract organic traffic, rank in search, or have high-quality backlinks for updates rather than deleting them outright.
  • Remove: Consider removal when the topic is no longer relevant, no longer aligns with the strategy, or the content cannot be made useful again through improvements.

CMI’s 2026 interviews offer a question to help guide the decision: “If we were creating this today, would we still make it?” This is an approach used by an interviewed team, not a platform rule; the article also emphasizes that content should not be retired simply because it is old.

Fix the content when updating; plan what happens to the URL when removing

Updating means more than changing the date. It can involve adjusting content to match search intent, correcting or removing outdated information, adding useful new information, and fixing broken links.

At Procrustes, our content services also focus on the questions customers genuinely care about: we plan and write articles around those questions and keep the content updated.

For website migrations, a 2024 article on Neil Patel’s website recommends using 301 redirects to send old URLs to the most relevant new pages rather than redirecting everything to the homepage. If no relevant page exists, consider creating replacement content or removing the old URL. This is practical advice for migration scenarios, not a requirement to redirect every retired page.

Content audits and decisions on what to keep: perspectives from across the web

Beyond identifying pages to delete, what can a content audit reveal?

It can reveal content gaps for different audience personas and stages of the journey, helping teams prioritize high-value areas and avoid duplicating effort. An audit can also uncover inconsistencies in terminology, formatting, or presentation; teams can save examples worth following and examples to avoid when developing or improving content guidelines. These findings can inform future planning and do not all call for deleting pages.

How can teams make ongoing decisions about what content to keep or remove?

Teams can schedule weekly or biweekly discussions, review a small batch of material each time, and decide item by item whether to keep it as is, merge and update it, or remove it. They can also assign someone to play devil’s advocate and challenge the reasoning behind each decision. This is a maintenance workflow particularly suited to teams that need to work through large volumes of content repeatedly; the frequency and number of items reviewed each time can be adjusted to available resources.

What should you do if AI frequently cites a page you planned to retire?

First, check whether the cited content is accurate and complete, and whether the page can be updated. During a content cleanup, Sitecore found that AI frequently cited older pages slated for retirement, so the team updated them instead to preserve their existing authority while correcting the information. This was one team’s experience, not a rule that every cited page must be kept; you still need to assess whether the content is worth improving.

When should news content be reviewed?

While a topic remains of interest, news-related content should be updated as needed as events develop, rather than waiting for a scheduled audit. For other types of articles, a significant ranking drop can signal a need for review. Teams can examine the new angles, information, or formats used by pages that have since overtaken theirs, then assess whether those approaches could improve the reader experience. Minor ranking fluctuations do not necessarily mean a rewrite is needed.

References

  1. Content Standards in Design Systemswww.nngroup.com · 2024-05-03T17:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Beyond identifying pages to delete, what can a content audit reveal?
  2. When to Update Blog Content & Why You Shouldwww.semrush.com · 2024-10-11T08:45:00Z — Discusses: When should news content be reviewed?
  3. Content Migration Alone Is Not An Effective Content Strategywww.nngroup.com · 2015-04-05T16:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
  4. Your Outdated Content Lives Forever in AI Search: Here's How To Manage Itcontentmarketinginstitute.com · 2026-08-13T10:00:00.000Z — Discusses: How can teams make ongoing decisions about what content to keep or remove?; What should you do if AI frequently cites a page you planned to retire?
  5. B2BContent矩陣:不只是策略,更是增長引擎tenten.co · 2025-04-20T07:26:10.000Z — Discusses: Beyond identifying pages to delete, what can a content audit reveal?
  6. Neil Patel’s Website Migration Checklistneilpatel.com · 2024-08-12T19:00:00+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
  7. Why Your Best Content Strategy Is Subtractioncontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: How can teams make ongoing decisions about what content to keep or remove?
  8. Content Inventory and Auditing 101www.nngroup.com · 2020-09-27T16:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
  9. SEO Tasks to Boost Your Site's Performance and Usabilitywww.semrush.com · 2025-05-05T10:15:00Z — Source used in the article above.
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp