Skip to content
×

How do you audit content based on performance and search intent?

A content audit should assess performance data and search intent separately, then interpret them together. Start by creating a content inventory and organizing search impressions, clicks, and conversions by page type. Then spot-check whether pages answer users’ questions and whether calls to action match their needs. The aim is not just to identify low-traffic articles, but to decide which content is worth keeping, updating, rewriting, consolidating, or removing so that improvements support the website’s goals.

Start with an inventory and clarify your audit goals

In a 2020 article, NN/g distinguishes between two activities: a content inventory records “what content exists,” while a content audit assesses “how good the content is and whether it needs attention.” Before making substantial changes, list the pages or assets and record their names, formats, URLs, creation dates, authors, and metadata.

Next, clarify the goals the content should support. Semrush’s explanation of content audits lists metrics such as page views, bounce rate, and conversion rate, and connects the assessment findings to business goals. You can organize inventory fields into:

  • Basic information: record the content’s name, type, and creation date.
  • Performance data: record search, traffic, and conversion performance.
  • Quality assessments: flag outdated information, gaps in topic coverage, and possible actions.

Compare pages by type and spot-check high- and low-performing content

In a 2025 article, Screaming Frog shares a process that starts with understanding the website’s technical architecture. Next, group URLs by page type, such as product category pages, product detail pages, location pages, and blog posts. Then compile non-branded search and organic traffic data for each group.

Comparison metrics include the total number of keywords and the number ranking in the top ten, non-branded search impressions and clicks, sign-ups or sales, and counts of new and total users. Next, select high- and low-performing pages from each group for manual review. Record differences in the data alongside content issues rather than deciding what to keep solely on traffic levels.

If you are unsure which pages to start with, a 2024 Semrush article recommends prioritizing important pages with average rankings between positions 3 and 10. These pages already have a ranking foothold and may still have room for improvement. This is the article’s prioritization advice, not a search engine rule, and it does not guarantee that updates will improve rankings.

Check each page: What is the searcher trying to do, and does the content meet that need?

Checking search intent involves more than confirming that keywords appear. Using “best running shoes” as an example, Neil Patel’s article advises first identifying whether users want to buy, compare, or read reviews, then checking whether the page provides the information they need.

At Procrustes, we turn questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.

  • Answers and topics: Does the content answer searchers’ questions, cover relevant topics, and provide information that is accurate and still applicable?
  • Structure and readability: Are headings, paragraphs, and lists easy to scan, and does multimedia aid understanding?
  • Next steps: Do calls to action match what searchers want to do on the page and their current stage in the user journey?

After spot-checking, record specific issues and proposed changes, such as adding comparison information, updating outdated content, or adjusting calls to action. These notes give subsequent revisions a clear focus rather than simply calling for “better content quality.”

Content audits: perspectives from across the web

Which pages should a content audit prioritize?

Priorities can vary depending on the improvement goals. Semrush recommends first reviewing important pages with average rankings between positions 3 and 10; Screaming Frog recommends optimizing high-intent pages before addressing groups of high-potential but lower-performing pages. The former focuses on pages that already have a ranking foothold, while the latter considers both intent and group-level potential. Both are recommendations for prioritizing work, not guarantees that improvements will raise rankings.

Can you draw audit conclusions from search intent tool scores alone?

Conclusions should not be based solely on tool scores. Clearscope, as described by Semrush, considers common topics, headings, word counts, and wording among high-ranking pages and provides an intent alignment score. This information can offer clues to missing topics, but you still need to check whether your own pages actually meet searchers’ needs. A competitor’s use of a particular term does not mean your content necessarily needs to copy it.

Does underperforming content always need to be deleted?

Not necessarily. During an audit, you can consider updating, rewriting, consolidating, or removing content based on its condition and the website’s goals. Pages with outdated information may benefit from updates. For groups of promising but lower-performing pages, consider reoptimizing the content or improving design and calls to action. Screaming Frog also suggests retiring low-quality content and setting up redirects, but poor performance alone does not mean a page must be deleted.

Besides topic coverage, what else can you check when spot-checking content quality?

Check whether the content demonstrates relevant expertise or genuine experience and cites credible sources. Also consider whether author biographies and the content itself help readers assess credibility. Screaming Frog also recommends checking whether content is useful and distinctive. These are all areas for manual review; do not fabricate experience, author backgrounds, or information to pass an audit.

References

  1. Content Inventory and Auditing 101www.nngroup.com · 2020-09-27T16:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.
  2. 7-Step Ecommerce Website Audit to Boost Conversionswww.semrush.com · 2024-05-14T08:30:00Z — Discusses: Which pages should a content audit prioritize?
  3. How to Do an Enterprise SEO Audit the Right Waywww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2025-06-30T09:00:51+00:00 — Discusses: Which pages should a content audit prioritize?; Does underperforming content always need to be deleted?
  4. What is a content audit?www.semrush.com · 2025-01-10T10:39:00Z — Discusses: Does underperforming content always need to be deleted?
  5. AI SEO Software: 12 Tools for Speed and Success in 2024www.semrush.com · 2023-11-03T16:54:00Z — Discusses: Can you draw audit conclusions from search intent tool scores alone?
  6. Does Keyword Density Still Matter in SEO?neilpatel.com · 2023-12-20T20:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Can you draw audit conclusions from search intent tool scores alone?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp