Skip to content
×

How should creation and publication be distinguished, and how should decisions about each be made?

Creation and publication call for separate decisions. Creation turns ideas into work through exploration and expression. Publication asks another question: can this work convey what we truly want to say to this audience at this moment? This commentary from Content Marketing Institute argues that work can be meaningful as soon as it is completed, without needing exposure to prove its value. Creating consistently and publishing thoughtfully are not contradictory: the former develops skills, while the latter determines when, how, and even whether to share.

Creation starts with expression, not a need for exposure

The creative process can begin with curiosity, intuition, or a need to clarify ideas. Writing an article, drawing a sketch, and drafting a script are all ways to give thoughts concrete form. In this commentary’s view, completing that process can be worthwhile in itself; the work does not have to be public to have value.

For example, writing a letter may simply help someone understand their feelings. Putting it in a drawer afterward does not erase its meaning. Similarly, some ideas are useful for practice or exploration and do not necessarily need an audience. A clever concept alone is no reason to invest in an expensive marketing campaign. This is not a rejection of sharing, but a refusal to tie every act of creation to a demand for immediate publication.

Publication requires considering the audience, purpose, and context

Once the work is complete, the question shifts from “What do we want to express?” to “Will publishing it convey that message appropriately?” The considerations proposed in the original article can be summarized as follows:

  • Representation: Does this content represent us and align with our brand voice and values?
  • Timing: Is now the right time to share, or are we simply feeling an urge to respond quickly?
  • Audience and purpose: Will the audience understand the message? What help can the content offer, and how?

The original author’s advice is to publish if the answers to “Is now the right time?” and “Is this what we want to say publicly at this moment?” are both yes. If the answer is still “maybe” or “not yet,” hold off. This is a decision-making approach proposed in the commentary, not a hard-and-fast rule that every piece of work must follow.

In our content services at Procrustes, for example, we use the questions our clients genuinely care about to guide the articles we plan, write, and regularly update.

Building a creative habit does not mean publishing every piece

The original article introduces Seth Godin’s encouragement to create and share regularly. It interprets this as a way to develop skills and confidence through practice rather than chase viral success or wait for perfection. But the author also cautions against reducing this idea to a productivity technique. Creators may become so focused on meeting performance targets and completing publishing tasks that they stop exploring and overlook the need for careful judgment.

Bringing creation and publication together, then, does not mean “publish as soon as it is done.” It means keep creating, then make a separate decision about whether to make the work public. The author values authenticity, usefulness, and lasting relevance over viral reach. When deciding whether to hold off, consider whether the message is appropriate and consistent with the strategy. Teams need agreement not only on tone but also on values to distinguish deliberate restraint from simply being afraid to publish.

Creation and publication: perspectives from across the web

Do sharing regularly and holding off on publication contradict each other?

Not necessarily. Seth Godin encourages regular creation and sharing as a way to grow through practice. The article’s author points out that this does not mean every piece must be made public as soon as it is finished. The key is not to let the pursuit of perfection stop you from expressing yourself, while still exercising judgment about what you publish. For each piece, the message and timing can still guide a decision to hold off.

When an event is trending, is a quick response or a clever idea enough to justify publishing?

Not necessarily. The article’s author argues that when speed becomes the priority, judgment and strategy may take a back seat. Even a clever content idea needs to be assessed for its relevance to the brand, the event, and the intended message. If the aim is simply to seize on a trending topic, there may be no need to publish immediately—or at all. This is the author’s judgment about marketing situations, not a claim that all real-time responses are inappropriate.

Does keeping work private or failing to go viral mean it has no value?

The article’s author does not think so. Some work serves as practice, exploration, or a way to clarify feelings and does not necessarily need an audience. For the author, creative work can be judged by its authenticity, usefulness, and lasting relevance, rather than solely by whether it goes viral. This is one way to assess value, not a claim that exposure and reach never matter.

References

  1. Why Content Restraint May Be the Most Overlooked Marketing Strategycontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Do sharing regularly and holding off on publication contradict each other?; When an event is trending, is a quick response or a clever idea enough to justify publishing?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp