Skip to content
×

Should Content Strategy Focus on Quantity, Quality, or Subtraction?

Quantity, quality, and subtraction address different problems; there is no need to choose just one. To understand audience responses, publishing more can help gather feedback. To provide useful, distinctive content, invest in quality. When existing content is repetitive, outdated, or contradictory, the next great piece alone cannot solve the problem. A more reasonable balance is to publish to learn about your audience, use quality to meet their needs, and make cleaning up older content part of the strategy, rather than treating “do more” as the default answer.

Increase output to learn, not to guarantee results

A Content Marketing Institute (CMI) article on quantity versus quality summarizes the case for quantity this way: publishing more content provides more real-time data to see which topics resonate. This is a strategic argument for increasing output, not a claim that publishing more will necessarily generate more business opportunities or citations.

The same author also cautions that learning from what you publish and deciding what to keep are two different things. He says he has not seen quantity-focused teams go back and clean up content that failed to resonate. This is the author’s observation, not a basis for generalizing about all teams. When adopting a quantity-focused strategy, it is worth first asking:

  • What do we want this batch of content to help us learn about the audience?
  • How will the feedback inform the next batch of topics?
  • Will someone be responsible for reviewing content that did not work?

To improve quality, first decide which audiences to focus on

The case for quality is to produce less but do it better, with particular emphasis on useful human experience that is difficult to replicate. Improving quality is not just about polishing prose; it also means considering whether the content is worth the audience’s time. In CMI’s recommendations for 2026, compiled in late 2025, contributors advocated focusing on what a brand does well rather than trying to be on every platform. The goal was to create newsletters worth opening and articles worth reading.

Anticipating tighter budgets and growing uncertainty, Zontee Hou recommended prioritizing difficult problems faced by high-value customer segments over broad appeal. This advice depends on those conditions; it is not a universal rule that every brand should narrow its audience.

At Procrustes, our content services turn the questions customers genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

Subtraction addresses existing content, not just publishing fewer pieces

The article on quantity and quality makes a key distinction: producing less is not the same as actively removing content. The author argues that continually adding without pruning can leave a collection of published content that is repetitive or even contradictory. Even if every piece is carefully crafted, that can only slow the buildup; it cannot automatically keep older perspectives in step with market changes.

The article gives the example of a 2022 opinion piece that is still being displayed and still ranks in search results, even though its perspective no longer reflects the market. This is not an argument for deleting all older articles. It is a reminder to assess two things separately: how good the content was when it was created, and whether it is still relevant today.

Decide first how to use the resources AI saves

In an October 2026 article, Robert Rose argues that greater efficiency frees up capacity whose use has yet to be decided; it is not a benefit in itself. He gives the example of a campaign that originally needed only one landing page but expanded to nine, criticizing how easily more demands can consume the extra capacity. This is the author’s argument and example, not data showing broadly applicable results.

Before adopting AI, then, it is worth deciding: should the resources saved go toward testing more topics, developing original content in greater depth, or organizing existing content? Without that choice, faster production may still leave you unsure about what needs to improve in your content.

Content strategy: perspectives from across the web

Does publishing more content help earn AI citations?

Increasing publishing volume should not be treated as a guarantee of earning citations. Research cited by Robert Rose shows a decline in the overlap between pages cited in AI Overviews and Google's top 10 results. Based on this, he argues that the connection between traditional search rankings and AI citations is weakening. However, the data does not directly compare publishing volume with citation performance, so it cannot establish that publishing more is necessarily ineffective.

What can differences in video counts among popular channels tell us?

Popular channels can differ greatly in how much they publish. In Backlinko's ranking of popular channels, some have fewer than 200 videos, while others have more than 500,000. The article's author argues that both quality-focused and quantity-focused approaches can work. However, this is only a comparison within ranking data; it cannot establish that channels succeeded because they produced more or fewer videos, nor can it be applied directly to other content formats.

Why make a point of considering removal when planning content?

When looking for ways to improve something, people may think only of adding and overlook removal. A study cited by CMI found that, in tasks involving improvements to structures, designs, or articles, people tended to add things and overlook subtraction, even when removal was objectively the better fix. When discussing how to improve content, it can therefore help to explicitly include removal as an option, rather than asking only what else to add. However, the study examined specific improvement tasks; it cannot directly establish that all content teams behave the same way.

References

  1. AI Made More Content, But It Didn't Make More Authoritycontentmarketinginstitute.com · 2026-10-19T10:00:00.000Z — Discusses: Does publishing more content help earn AI citations?
  2. Most Popular YouTube Channels & Searchesbacklinko.com · 2024-01-08T13:20:46-05:00 — Discusses: What can differences in video counts among popular channels tell us?
  3. 42 Experts Name the Most Important Content Marketing Trends for 2026contentmarketinginstitute.com · 2025-12-09T11:00:00.000Z — Source used in the article above.
  4. Why Your Best Content Strategy Is Subtractioncontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Why make a point of considering removal when planning content?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp