How do you decide whether to remove content and handle its removal?
When deciding whether to remove content, first assess whether it still meets user needs, content standards, and business goals. Then choose whether to keep, update, or remove it. Content should not be deleted simply because it is outdated, nor must it be kept just because it still has search value. Once removal is planned, confirm who makes and carries out the decision, whether archiving is needed, which external sources link to the content, and how removal might affect search performance. The inventory and audit records also need updating. This article covers website content that teams can manage themselves, not requests for third-party platforms to delete posts.
Start with a comprehensive audit, then decide what to keep, update, or remove
In its 2020 article on content inventories and audits, Nielsen Norman Group notes that completing an inventory is not enough: teams must review the results as a whole and address problematic, inaccurate, or outdated content. An audit should do more than identify lower-quality pages. Teams should consider the findings together and record a clear status for each piece of content:
- Keep: After a comprehensive review, decide to leave the content as it is.
- Update: Specify what needs improvement and assign someone to take responsibility, rather than simply marking it “needs revision.”
- Remove: Have relevant stakeholders, content owners, and creators jointly review the removal proposal, especially when it involves major changes.
If it is unclear whether content meets user needs, standards, or performance goals, first note the questions in the audit spreadsheet, then seek additional context from the team or creators. For example, an article containing outdated information still requires a decision about whether to update or remove it. Being “outdated” signals a need for action, not necessarily removal.
Search value alone should not determine whether content stays
A 2021 article from Screaming Frog argues that even content with search engine optimization (SEO) value can be streamlined or removed if doing so serves the business’s overall interests. This does not mean ignoring search performance. Instead, compare content’s SEO value to help decide how to streamline or reposition it, rather than using search value alone to decide what stays.
When business direction and search value are not aligned, assess them together. Content with search value does not have to remain unchanged, but a decision to remove it should still account for the effects on search performance.
Before removal, confirm who will do it and what needs to be kept
Nielsen Norman Group’s 2022 article on content governance states that removal requires a clear process. Before removing content, teams should at least confirm:
- Who makes the final decision, and who removes the content from the content management system?
- Does it need to be archived? If so, why, for how long, and where?
- Which external sources link to this content, and are redirects needed?
- What SEO implications might deletion have?
Consider these questions case by case; not every removal requires archiving or redirects. Once content has changed, update the inventory and audit records promptly, as recommended in the 2020 audit article. Tools can help maintain the inventory, but teams still need to monitor content and keep audit records up to date.
Content removal: perspectives from across the web
Can performance be compared by author or content category during an audit?
Yes. Filtering and comparing performance by author or content category can reveal differences worth examining further. For example, teams can compare categories to see whether priority categories have room for improvement. However, differences between authors or categories are only starting points for further analysis. These comparisons alone cannot establish who is responsible for good or poor performance, nor are they enough to justify removal.
If a team frequently struggles to determine whether content meets expectations, how can it improve future audits?
Before starting or continuing content creation, document user needs, content standards, goals, and success metrics. These records give teams a clearer basis for discussion in future audits. Teams can also seek context from colleagues or creators. If it remains unclear whether an individual piece of content meets expectations, consider its context rather than deciding whether to keep or remove it based on a single metric.
References
- Conducting an SEO Content Audit: 6 Things You Might Be Overlookingwww.screamingfrog.co.uk · 2021-11-15T13:37:48+00:00 — Discusses: Can performance be compared by author or content category during an audit?
- Content Inventory and Auditing 101www.nngroup.com · 2020-09-27T16:00:00+0000 — Discusses: If a team frequently struggles to determine whether content meets expectations, how can it improve future audits?
- Content Strategy 101www.nngroup.com · 2022-11-13T17:00:00+0000 — Source used in the article above.


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.