How to craft compelling headlines: start with readers’ questions and deliver on your promises
To craft a compelling headline, first establish what question the article answers and who it is for. Then use language familiar to those readers to explain what they will gain from reading it. You can lead with a question, a reason, or a specific audience, but when evaluating a headline, do not ask only whether it grabs attention. Also check whether it fits the topic and whether the content delivers on its promises. A good headline makes people want to read—and does not leave them feeling misled afterward.
Find readers’ questions before reaching for attention-grabbing adjectives
A headline should use language familiar to its intended readers. In a 2021 article, Ahrefs noted that knowing the terms people commonly search for helps you refine a page’s language and develop headlines. Welly’s copywriting advice likewise emphasizes clarifying the audience and communication goal first, so you do not finish writing without knowing what you are trying to say.
As part of our services at Procrustes, we turn the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.
For example, suppose the content is for writers new to SEO. Instead of simply writing “Powerful Writing Secrets,” you could try “How to Write an SEO Article: From Keywords to Paragraph Structure.” This is a wording example, not a guarantee of results. It assumes the article actually explains those steps rather than merely recommending tools.
Distill a headline from the content, or draft one before building an outline
There is no fixed order for developing a headline. In a 2004 article, Jill Whalen shared her personal approach: finish the page copy first, then select the most relevant keyword phrases to write the headline. If no clear focus emerges, the copy may need rewriting. She also preferred rephrasing rather than copying a full sentence directly from the body. This reflects her personal writing experience, not a current search platform rule.
Another approach is to plan the topic first. A 2026 SEO article from Da Vinci recommends selecting keywords, then drafting a headline and an outline with main points and subpoints. It lists approaches such as asking a question, explaining reasons, and targeting an audience. Although the two methods follow different sequences, both can help check whether the headline and content align. Here are sample headlines based on those approaches:
- Question-led: “How Do You Write an SEO Article?” This works for content that directly answers a practical question.
- Reason-led: “Why Does an SEO Article Need a Clear Outline?” The body must explain the reasons.
- Audience-led: “An Introduction to SEO Articles for First-Time Writers.” The content must meet beginners’ needs.
Check that headlines are relevant and credible, not just gimmicks
In a 2020 article, NN/g cautioned that using popular headlines unrelated to the content to attract clicks can erode visitors’ trust, making them less willing to click again in the future. Negative feedback from others may also affect readers who have not yet visited. You can still spark curiosity, but not by creating false expectations.
Before choosing a headline, check it against the principles above:
- Is the topic clear? Can readers tell from the headline what the article is about?
- Is the wording appropriate? Does it use terms the intended readers would understand and search for?
- Does the content deliver on the promise? Does the body answer the headline’s questions, explain the relevant reasons, and meet the needs of the readers it addresses?
How to craft compelling headlines: perspectives from across the web
Does an SEO article’s headline have to put the keyword first?
There is no need to sacrifice natural phrasing just to put a keyword first. Da Vinci’s SEO writing advice is to include the keyword naturally once in the headline, placing it as early as possible without forcing it. Welly also recommends keeping headlines concise and engaging, with the keyword near the beginning. These are writing recommendations, not a guarantee that a fixed keyword position will secure rankings.
Can numbers make a headline more appealing?
Numbers can be used where appropriate to give readers a concrete expectation of an article’s scope or the time required. Welly gives examples such as “6 Key Points” and “A Quick 5-Minute Guide” to spark curiosity. But the numbers should match the content—for example, the article should actually list six points rather than exaggerating arbitrarily to attract clicks. This is an approach worth trying, not a guarantee of results.
Is it still worth putting effort into a headline for a topic with very low search volume?
It is still worth making the headline clear and appealing, but first consider whether visibility in search is the main goal. Forum replies note that if no one searches for a term, even ranking first may be of questionable value. When there are few competitors, a clearly descriptive headline can still help attract clicks. This advice applies to a specific low-search-volume situation; it does not mean all niche topics lack value.
How do the considerations for marketing email subject lines differ from those for article headlines?
Email subject lines should likewise be clear, appealing, and honest with recipients. They also need to account for smaller mobile screens, where longer text may not display in full. If open rates are low, you can consider segmenting the audience and providing relevant content alongside adjusting the subject line. Results should not be attributed entirely to the subject line, nor should a fixed length be treated as a universal rule.
References
- Information Scent: How Users Decide Where to Go Nextwww.nngroup.com · 2020-02-02T17:00:00+0000 — Discusses: Can numbers make a headline more appealing?
- About Search Engine Title Tagswww.searchenginejournal.com · 2004-05-04T11:16:05+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- RankBrain What does it mean?Google 智慧演算法的概念與應用方法welly.tw · 2024-12-05T18:43:58.865Z — Discusses: Can numbers make a headline more appealing?
- GSC vs. GKP: Comparing Search Volumes for 72k Keywords [A Study by Ahrefs]ahrefs.com · 2021-11-03T16:00:40+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Website推廣的宣傳方法有多少種?ithelp.ithome.com.tw — Discusses: How do the considerations for marketing email subject lines differ from those for article headlines?
- 文案怎麼寫才吸睛?FB、IG、Ads文案全解析,3招寫出吸睛Contentwelly.tw · 2023-03-06T04:17:22.101Z — Source used in the article above.
- Website流量完整攻略!5大熱門Website分析排名工具與6個流量成長方法www.awoo.ai · 2020-11-06T02:00:34+00:00 — Discusses: How do the considerations for marketing email subject lines differ from those for article headlines?
- If I have a breaking news and I am the first to publish the story how can I ensure Google indexes it fast and ranks it topwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is it still worth putting effort into a headline for a topic with very low search volume?
- If I have a breaking news and I am the first to publish the story how can I ensure Google indexes it fast and ranks it topwebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Is it still worth putting effort into a headline for a topic with very low search volume?
- SEO Creating content才會上首頁?拆解 Google 喜歡的 SEO 架構www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2026-02-26T12:09:51+08:00 — Discusses: Does an SEO article’s headline have to put the keyword first?
- Medium SEO 怎麼設定? 4 技巧讓 Medium 文章排名更靠前welly.tw · 2025-01-17T08:52:50.664Z — Discusses: Does an SEO article’s headline have to put the keyword first?
- 信件總是被忽略?試試看Follow up Email提高郵件互動率!www.awoo.ai · 2019-10-07T02:18:19+00:00 — Discusses: How do the considerations for marketing email subject lines differ from those for article headlines?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.