Skip to content
×

Does sharing your best content on external platforms erode your owned audience?

There is a risk, but sharing your best content does not necessarily erode your owned audience. A Content Marketing Institute (CMI) article notes that sharing your most valuable ideas on external platforms may also create value for those platforms and their algorithms. Yet hiding all that value may make your brand difficult to discover. The key is to share content to reach audiences while giving them a reason to engage with your brand directly. Reaching people on external platforms is not the same as establishing a direct relationship with them.

The key distinction is between reach and audience relationships

Having content seen on external platforms does not mean a brand can maintain ongoing contact with viewers. The CMI article draws a lesson from traditional publishers: they once traded audience relationships, data, and trust for platform reach, and many later turned to rebuilding direct connections with their audiences. This is the article’s account of industry experience, not proof that every brand will face the same outcome.

The article also acknowledges that one cost of sharing your best ideas externally is helping other platforms build their business models. It uses a music analogy: unlike fans, answer engines do not buy tickets or merchandise. This reminds brands that having their content used is not the same as receiving a return. However, the article provides no data showing how much audience loss external distribution causes.

Owning the work is not the same as owning the distribution channels

Another CMI article distinguishes between “owned platforms” and “owned content assets”: brands can control the intellectual property, narrative, and creative direction of original shows and videos while still relying on third-party platforms to reach viewers. External distribution therefore does not necessarily mean relinquishing control of the work, nor does it mean a direct audience relationship has been established.

  • Bilt’s release of Roomies on TikTok and Instagram shows how a brand can own original programming while distributing it through external platforms.
  • Dick’s Sporting Goods brought an original film to ESPN, likewise showing how a brand can control the work while relying on an external channel to reach viewers.

These examples illustrate a way to manage and distribute content, not a guarantee of results. They do not establish that external distribution will necessarily increase subscriptions or never draw audiences away from owned platforms.

Do not just ask how much to share—ask what audiences gain by coming back

CMI’s proposed approach is neither to gate all content nor to leave only hollow promotion on external platforms. Instead, it is to offer real value as a way to build audience relationships. In practice, that means creating content worth watching or listening to, expanding its reach through external platforms, and then directing audiences back to an owned website to read educational content and engage more deeply with the brand.

Following this approach, you can evaluate a sharing strategy by asking two questions: is the external content worth the audience’s time, and does the owned platform offer content worth exploring further? Audiences need a concrete reason to return to the brand’s website; the brand’s desire for more traffic is not enough to bring them back. This is a strategic direction, not a formula that guarantees viewers will return.

At Procrustes, our content work turns the questions clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

Sharing your best content on external platforms: perspectives from across the web

Can keeping your best content behind a paywall or registration requirement prevent audience loss?

Not necessarily. The CMI article notes that putting all your valuable content behind a paywall or registration requirement may make your brand difficult to discover. That does not mean all content should be freely accessible, either. The article does not compare how different access restrictions affect audience retention, so it cannot establish how much content each brand should make available with or without restrictions.

Does owning original shows or videos mean you own the viewing audience?

No. A brand can control the intellectual property, narrative, and creative direction of its original work, but if it distributes that work through third-party platforms, its reach still depends on external channels. This model suits brands that want to retain their creative assets while using external distribution. Ownership of the work alone does not demonstrate that a brand has established a direct audience relationship.

Does an answer engine’s use of content mean the brand receives an equivalent return?

No. The CMI article points out that sharing your most valuable ideas externally may also help platforms build their business models and supply content for their algorithms. Unlike an actual audience, however, answer engines do not buy tickets or merchandise. The warning is that having content used does not mean the brand receives a corresponding return. The article does not quantify how that use affects a brand’s audience or revenue.

References

  1. Why Your Distribution Strategy Is Stunting Your Audience Growthcontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Can keeping your best content behind a paywall or registration requirement prevent audience loss?; Does an answer engine’s use of content mean the brand receives an equivalent return?
  2. Why Content Marketing Is Outpacing Inbound Now (Even on Rented Land)contentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Does owning original shows or videos mean you own the viewing audience?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp