How should brands decide which content to add or optimize?
Brands should identify audience needs, shortcomings in existing pages, and business goals before deciding whether to add or optimize content. If a relevant page already exists but its information is incomplete or it does not fully address search intent, improving it may take priority. If the site genuinely lacks content that addresses a need, consider adding it. Competitor keywords and ranking changes can offer clues about what to review, but they are not sufficient reasons to publish new articles. The point is not to keep putting something new on the site, but to make content more relevant to audience needs and deliver the unique value the brand can offer.
First, decide which need to address
There is no fixed balance between adding and optimizing content that works for every brand. In an October 2026 interview with Search Engine Journal, Jonathan discussed a situation involving stagnant traffic and no budget: analyze the entire site first, then decide whether to improve existing pages or fill topic gaps based on the problems identified. He would prioritize testing content aimed at commercial and transactional searches rather than pursuing informational traffic alone.
This is a testing recommendation for a specific situation, not a suggestion that all brands should abandon awareness-stage content. His assessment that some top-of-funnel, or awareness-stage, traffic is difficult to convert cannot be applied directly to every website. Brands should first clarify whether the content work is intended to help people compare options, encourage purchases, or answer existing customers’ questions, then choose the appropriate pages.
At Procrustes, we turn the questions customers genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.
If relevant pages already exist, identify what is worth improving
If the site already has content on the same topic, review each page for shortcomings before deciding whether another article is needed. A 2024 Semrush article proposed the following checks:
- Information quality and timeliness: Is the content accurate, still relevant, and more helpful than competitors’ content?
- Search intent and wording: Does it answer the questions users actually have? Are target keywords used naturally in the title, headings, and body text?
- Links and next steps: Does it link to and receive links from related pages on the site, and guide readers toward purchasing, signing up, or reading more?
Advice from Warrior Forum and Semrush differs on pages that already rank well. One Warrior Forum contributor argued that existing content should not be changed if its on-page SEO is good and it already ranks on the first page of search results, while Semrush recommended reviewing important pages that still have room for improvement. The former is a forum opinion, not a search engine rule. A more cautious approach is to identify specific shortcomings first: do not rewrite content merely because “it is time for an update,” but do not ignore outdated information just because a page ranks well.
New content needs both a gap to fill and unique value
Keywords for which competitors rank but your site does not can suggest possible directions. A 2021 Semrush article described these gaps as opportunities both to add content and to optimize existing pages, and suggested considering search intent, estimated search volume, and ranking difficulty. Therefore, “not ranking” does not necessarily mean “having no relevant page”; the site’s existing content still needs to be checked.
Once the need for new content is confirmed, ask what more the brand can offer. In interviews published by Content Marketing Institute in 2026, interviewees emphasized the value of original research, specific customer stories, a distinctive writing style, and expertise.
Include post-purchase content in the audit, rather than limiting opportunities for new content to the blog. For example, if a product help center already contains an answer, improving the documentation may come first. If it does not yet address a question the audience is asking, a new page can be planned.
Choosing brand content: perspectives from across the web
Should deleting old content also be considered during a content audit?
Removing content can be part of an audit, but it should not be done indiscriminately. A Content Marketing Institute author argued that content accumulated over time may be repetitive or even contradictory, and advocated proactively removing unimportant content. By contrast, a forum user who serves local businesses said they try to limit deletions or changes during redesigns and carefully monitor what is removed. These views apply to different situations; whether to delete content should still be decided by reviewing each page’s purpose and problems.
Should brands use the same approach to increase their chances of being cited or mentioned?
Not necessarily. Seer Interactive distinguished between two opportunities: adding or updating content may help improve the chances of being cited, while increasing brand mentions is more likely to require media exposure and take longer to build. This is guidance for choosing a direction, not a guarantee. Brands should first clarify whether they want to improve citations or mentions, then decide whether content work alone can address that goal.
Does a ranking drop after adding or optimizing content mean something was done wrong?
A ranking drop alone is not enough to draw that conclusion, but it can be a signal to investigate. Semrush recommended tracking keyword rankings after adding articles, launching landing pages, or optimizing a website. If rankings decline, check whether the page matches search intent, is easy to read, and has appropriate tags and heading structure, among other things. Ranking changes can help assess the work, but cannot by themselves establish which change caused the result.
When using AI to help with planning, is a list of URLs enough to decide whether to add or optimize content?
No—a URL list alone is not enough to decide. It can give AI an initial picture of the site’s existing pages, helping it suggest improving a page rather than creating another one. However, Semrush noted that this method depends on AI interpreting URLs, so it is imperfect. The list is best used as a starting point for an audit; the actual content still needs to be reviewed before deciding whether an existing page is suitable for optimization.
References
- Keywords Suddenly Dropped in Rank on Google?www.warriorforum.com — Source used in the article above.
- What's Next for Your Brand Website?contentmarketinginstitute.com · 2026-08-19T10:00:00.000Z — Source used in the article above.
- AI Visibility Is Lying to You: There’s No One-Size-Fits-All AI Search KPIwww.seerinteractive.com · 2026-08-31T15:59:48-05:00 — Discusses: Should brands use the same approach to increase their chances of being cited or mentioned?
- How to do keyword research with Claude and Semrushwww.semrush.com · 2026-09-10T17:12:00Z — Discusses: When using AI to help with planning, is a list of URLs enough to decide whether to add or optimize content?
- Why Your Best Content Strategy Is Subtractioncontentmarketinginstitute.com — Discusses: Should deleting old content also be considered during a content audit?
- Changing website theme / local ranklocalsearchforum.com — Discusses: Should deleting old content also be considered during a content audit?
- Flat Traffic, No Budget: What Ziff Davis’ Jonathan Berthold Tests Firstwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-10-27T12:00:41+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Organic Keywords: What Are They & How to Find Themwww.semrush.com · 2021-02-25T15:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- 7-Step Ecommerce Website Audit to Boost Conversionswww.semrush.com · 2024-05-14T08:30:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- How Keyword Monitoring Can Transform Your Online Presencewww.semrush.com · 2023-11-20T12:20:00Z — Discusses: Does a ranking drop after adding or optimizing content mean something was done wrong?
- What is keyword analysis?www.semrush.com · 2025-01-10T11:42:00Z — Source used in the article above.


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.