Should Companies Publish Their Own Best-of Lists and Rank Themselves First?
Companies can consider publishing their own best-of lists, but they should not treat ranking themselves first as an essential strategy. Research and examples suggest that this content can gain search visibility and AI citations. But being cited does not mean earning buyers’ trust, nor does it prove that the results came from ranking yourself first. Companies should consider two questions separately: is the list worth creating, and is there enough justification for putting themselves first? Controlling the list is not, by itself, a reason to take the top spot.
Lists can gain visibility, but the data does not establish the effect of ranking yourself first
In 2025, Ahrefs’ Glen Allsopp studied 750 top-of-funnel prompts covering software, product, and agency recommendations. Of the source links obtained from ChatGPT, 43.8% were “best X” blog lists, including articles in which brands ranked themselves first. However, that figure includes both brand-owned websites and third-party sources. It does not represent the share of lists that recommend their own publishers, let alone those lists’ success rate.
Publishing a list also gives companies access to their own data. In an article published by Semrush in 2022, Alex Birkett noted that a company with writing skills and sufficient website authority could get its list into search results and collect its own click and conversion data. This reflects practical experience under specific conditions, not a guarantee that publishing a list will earn search rankings.
The debate is not just about visibility, but also about who endorses the top choice
Views differ on companies ranking themselves first. Allsopp recommends that agencies and SaaS companies publish self-promotional lists, arguing that these can help visitors understand crowded markets. Ross Hudgens, whom Allsopp quotes, also believes that a brand’s list can provide value even if it puts the brand first.
By contrast, when studying agency search results in 2025, Wil Reynolds viewed companies declaring themselves the best on lists they fully control as a way of manufacturing authority. Even if the practice appears effective, it may not earn the trust of people choosing an agency. A 2026 Search Engine Journal article goes further, calling it spam when companies rank themselves first on their own “best agencies” lists and emphasizing the independence of recommendation sources. These are the authors’ assessments, not official judgments by search platforms.
If you create a list, first decide how to handle self-recommendation
In a 2025 article, Ahrefs described its own more restrained approach. These practices offer an example, not a standard that all companies must follow:
- Keeping comparison articles below 0.5% of blog content, rather than creating one for every tool or use case.
- Not necessarily ranking itself first every time, and clearly identifying recommendations for its own product.
- Linking directly to alternatives so visitors can do their own research, rather than leaving them with only Ahrefs’ own offering.
Allsopp also acknowledged feeling frustrated during his research when he encountered overly self-promotional lists or lists that recommended alternatives without linking to them. Companies therefore need to consider more than where to rank themselves: are they willing to let readers make genuine comparisons? Ranking themselves lower is not necessarily the only answer, either. Allsopp considers it commendable, but notes that it may also mean marketing competitors. Companies still need to weigh that trade-off for themselves.
Companies publishing their own best-of lists: perspectives from across the web
Is it common for companies to rank themselves first in lists appearing in search results?
In 2025, Ahrefs examined 250 search results pages for “best X software” queries. Of these, 169, or 67.6%, included lists that ranked the article author’s company first. This shows that the practice was not uncommon in that study’s sample, but it cannot be generalized to all industries or search results, nor does it prove that ranking yourself first caused the content to rank in search.
If AI cites a company’s own list, does that mean ranking itself first works?
A single case is not enough to draw that conclusion. A Search Engine Journal article relays an observation by Nicholas Thompson: when asked about the best way to build an online store, ChatGPT recommended Shopify and cited Shopify’s list of e-commerce platforms, which ranked Shopify first. This is a case worth noting, but it does not establish that the top position led to the recommendation, nor does it guarantee the same outcome for other companies.
Beyond gaining visibility, what else can publishing your own list offer?
Publishing its own list can also give a company access to its own click and conversion data and potentially provide leverage in negotiations with the publishers of other established lists. A 2022 Semrush article describes these benefits on the condition that the company has writing skills and sufficient website authority. Under those conditions, the list may also appear in search results. This reflects the author’s practical experience under specific conditions, not a guarantee of successful negotiations or conversions.
References
- Why AI Recommends Your Competitor & What To Do About Itwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-08-03T17:30:55+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- Do Self-Promotional “Best” Lists Boost ChatGPT Visibility? Study of 26,283 Source URLsahrefs.com · 2025-12-04T08:30:19+00:00 — Discusses: Is it common for companies to rank themselves first in lists appearing in search results?
- Omniscient Digital Increases Share of Voice from Zero to 45.6% to Drive Podcast Downloadswww.semrush.com · 2022-05-05T17:08:00Z — Discusses: Beyond gaining visibility, what else can publishing your own list offer?
- Want to Rank in ChatGPT? Brute force repetition beats thought leadership, today.www.seerinteractive.com · 2025-02-07T12:12:56-05:00 — Source used in the article above.
- The Grounding Wars Are Coming: How AI Visibility Creates Its Own Black-Hat Playbookwww.searchenginejournal.com · 2026-06-24T10:00:21+00:00 — Discusses: If AI cites a company’s own list, does that mean ranking itself first works?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.