Should you use quotation marks when researching keyword competition with allintitle?
If you want to research which pages might compete with yours for a keyword, these public discussions suggest that it is best to start with searches without quotation marks and use quoted searches as a supplement. Unquoted searches can cover variations of the target phrase, while quoted searches let you examine exact phrase matches. This only determines the scope of your query; it does not tell you which pages have a ranking advantage. The counts of 191 and 70 in the discussions come from a 2011 example and should not be treated as current results or a benchmark for competition.
Quotation marks narrow the results to exact phrase matches
The original poster used the same set of words but obtained different result counts:
- Without quotation marks: allintitle: seo tips and tricks for beginners, which showed 191 results at the time.
- With quotation marks: allintitle: “seo tips and tricks for beginners”, which showed 70 results at the time.
Responses on Stack Exchange noted that quotation marks exclude results that do not exactly match the chosen phrase. The two numbers therefore reflect different query conditions, not conflicting estimates of the same set of results. Looking only at quoted results could mean overlooking pages that do not use the exact phrase but are still relevant to the target words.
In other words, a quoted search is not necessarily more suitable just because it is more precise. It can answer a narrower question, such as how many results match the complete phrase, but it cannot define the full set of relevant competing pages.
Identifying competing pages is not the same as assessing their ranking advantage
The original poster also asked whether having the exact phrase in a title makes a page more likely to rank higher. The responses in the discussions did not support that inference. One response argued that operators only change the results returned; they do not make Google assign extra weight based on the query format. Another said that pages matching the exact phrase do not necessarily rank better.
So “using quotation marks leaves only 70 results” does not mean “you only need to beat these 70 competitors.” Nor does it mean those pages necessarily have a ranking advantage over the other results. The numbers alone do not indicate actual rankings or show how difficult it would be to compete.
Start with broader results, then check exact phrase matches
Based on these discussions, you can approach your research in this order:
- First, look at results without quotation marks to avoid excluding variations of the phrase from the outset.
- Then use a quoted query to examine exact phrase matches as a supplement, rather than a replacement for the first step.
- When you return to the search terms you want to study, distinguish title-restricted results from ordinary search results. Do not treat the two as equivalent.
Another response recommended focusing on unquoted searches because users generally search without quotation marks. However, the discussions provided no statistics on how common this is, so it remains a participant’s reasoning rather than verified data. Overall, these discussions compare the scope of the two query formats and offer research suggestions. They should not be read as Google’s current official specification, nor do they establish how an exact phrase match in a title affects rankings.
Keyword competition with allintitle: perspectives from across the web
Does subtracting 70 from 191 mean there are 121 additional competitors?
No. The counts of 191 and 70 were results the original poster saw in 2011 under different query conditions. Although the difference is 121, the material does not list the results for either query or confirm whether the pages accounting for that difference were all actual competitors. The difference therefore cannot be treated as a count of additional competitors, nor does it indicate that the same results would appear today.
References
- SEO Question - allintitle with or without quoteswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO Question - allintitle with or without quoteswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO Question - allintitle with or without quoteswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
- SEO Question - allintitle with or without quoteswebmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Does subtracting 70 from 191 mean there are 121 additional competitors?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.