How Does Google Evaluate YMYL Content? Guideline Versions, Quality Standards, and the Role of Raters
Google’s Search Quality Rater Guidelines apply higher quality standards to YMYL content because inaccurate information could harm readers’ health, finances, or safety. Raters conduct manual evaluations and provide feedback; they do not directly determine page rankings. This article uses quotations from the October 2021 guidelines to explain why these standards are high. It also discusses the December 2022 framework update and later third-party interpretations separately; the historical version does not represent the full set of current rules.
YMYL focuses on the potential harm information could cause
An article published by awoo in 2022 quotes the October 2021 guidelines: low-quality YMYL pages could negatively affect a person’s happiness, health, financial stability, or safety, so very high Page Quality rating standards apply. The standards are higher not simply because a topic is highly specialized, but because readers could face real risks when acting on the information.
Semrush’s 2024 interpretation lists examples involving medical information, safety, law, and major life decisions:
- Inaccurate advice on improving credit scores could affect readers’ finances.
- Incorrect diet or fitness advice could lead to injury or other harm to health.
- Information about major decisions involving education, housing, and careers may also fall under YMYL.
These are examples provided in that article, not a current official classification list that can be applied directly to every website.
From E-A-T to E-E-A-T: keep versions and interpretations distinct
According to a 2023 Semrush article, Google updated its Quality Rater Guidelines in December 2022, adding “experience” to E-A-T to create E-E-A-T: experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness. This four-part framework was added later and is not part of the 2021 quotations above.
Semrush’s 2024 article states that raters assess YMYL content more strictly against these criteria. Yoast’s 2026 interpretation lists indicators to consider, including:
- Education, qualifications, work experience, or research experience relevant to the topic.
- Thorough explanations, credible references, and content that demonstrates depth of knowledge.
- Whether information is accurate and whether funding sources and potential biases are transparently disclosed.
Yoast also acknowledges that the exact evaluation process is unknown. These are third-party evaluation indicators, not an official fixed scoring rubric. Meeting these criteria does not guarantee a high rating.
Raters provide feedback rather than adjust website rankings
According to Yoast, feedback from quality raters helps Google understand whether search results meet expectations and is used to improve its algorithms; raters themselves do not directly affect rankings. The article also describes E-E-A-T as a framework for evaluating content quality rather than a direct ranking factor.
Manual evaluation of content quality and ranking by search systems are two different things. For YMYL content, the interpretations above emphasize thoroughly answering readers’ main questions and providing accurate information and credible supporting evidence. This does not mean that simply adding credentials or an author biography will secure a particular ranking.
Google’s Quality Rater Guidelines and YMYL: perspectives from across the web
Can a website’s good reputation compensate for quality problems on a YMYL page?
A website’s or creator’s reputation alone is not enough. Welly’s 2024 interpretation states that even if both have good reputations, this cannot compensate for a lack of E-E-A-T on an individual page. For YMYL, whether the content demonstrates sufficient expertise and trustworthiness still needs to be considered. This summarizes an approach to evaluation; it does not mean that meeting these conditions guarantees a high rating.
What can help indicate content’s authoritativeness and trustworthiness?
Yoast’s 2026 interpretation links authoritativeness to established credibility, expert recognition, and a reputation for accurate information. Trustworthiness involves transparency, accuracy, and disclosure of potential biases. The article also notes that a history of complaints, misinformation, or malicious behavior may affect the evaluation. These are indicators summarized by a third party, not a publicly disclosed fixed scoring formula.
Was E-A-T ever a standalone algorithm update?
A forum commenter argues that there was no single E-A-T algorithm update. According to their account, E-A-T was introduced for quality raters to use in 2015, and raters’ feedback may subsequently have indirectly influenced multiple algorithm adjustments. The commenter also explicitly acknowledges that they could be wrong, so this should be treated only as a personal interpretation of the history, not as official confirmation from Google.
References
- Is Google's EAT update the end for AM's with YMYL sites?www.warriorforum.com — Discusses: Was E-A-T ever a standalone algorithm update?
- 2022 最新 8 個重要的 SEO 趨勢,掌握數位轉型成長契機www.awoo.ai · 2022-01-19T02:08:57+00:00 — Source used in the article above.
- What are YMYL websites? How does Google evaluate these?yoast.com · 2026-08-04T11:02:00+00:00 — Discusses: What can help indicate content’s authoritativeness and trustworthiness?
- What Is YMYL & How Does It Affect SEO?www.semrush.com · 2024-06-20T08:59:00Z — Source used in the article above.
- Google E-E-A-T 如何評估?增加「Experience」2 大技巧分享!welly.tw · 2024-03-07T05:28:48.841Z — Discusses: Can a website’s good reputation compensate for quality problems on a YMYL page?
- What Is Google Panda? A Complete Guidewww.semrush.com · 2023-11-07T16:33:00Z — Source used in the article above.


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.