What Is Keyword Marketing? Visibility Benefits, Performance Measurement, and Competitive Constraints
Keyword marketing involves choosing search terms relevant to your business for use in website content and advertising, increasing the chances that people will find you when they search. It covers both organic and paid search, aiming to reach people interested in your products, services, or content and attract traffic, inquiries, and orders. However, greater visibility or higher rankings do not necessarily lead to sales. The results depend on how closely keywords match your business, how effectively your website persuades visitors, and the costs involved.
Organic search and paid advertising offer different paths to visibility
According to an introduction published by Semrush in 2024, keywords can be used in website content to gain organic search visibility or in paid search ads. For example, a business selling athletic shoes could start by researching terms directly related to its products, such as running shoes and athletic shoes, then identify search terms suitable for its advertising campaigns. The point is not simply to choose popular keywords, but to choose terms that match the business.
The article presents advertising as an option for quickly generating conversions or building brand awareness, but notes that its effects stop when the ads stop running. SEO, meanwhile, is not a shortcut to free results. A 2025 article by Da Vinci notes that a comprehensive SEO effort may involve improving website architecture, writing content, analyzing competitors, and reviewing website analytics.
At Procrustes, our services cover page planning, design, and functionality for the websites we work on, as well as planning content topics, writing and updating content, and managing visibility.
Measure inquiries and orders, not just search volume
One advantage of keyword marketing is that performance can be tracked, but different metrics answer different questions:
- Search volume: Shows approximately how many times a keyword is searched each month. It does not mean a website will receive that many visits.
- Website traffic: Shows how many visits search actually brings in. Visits should not be counted as sales.
- Inquiries and orders: Show whether visitors take the actions the business wants, helping you look beyond rankings.
The Da Vinci article notes that products, brand value, pricing, user experience, website speed, and checkout functionality can all affect whether visitors make a purchase. Its author suggests trying keyword advertising for a short period if results are uncertain. However, the view that “if paid advertising generates no inquiries, the outlook for SEO is not promising either” is the author’s advice for assessing prospects, not a rule that the two will necessarily produce the same results.
Assessing competition and costs takes more than a first-page ranking
In a PTT discussion, some participants describe the search terms “SEO” and “keyword marketing” as highly competitive. This observation comes from a specific discussion. It does not establish that competition is equally intense across all industries and keywords, or indicate how competitive those terms are today.
Assessing costs also requires more than comparing advertising spending with SEO quotes. The Da Vinci article emphasizes that saving money through SEO is not easy in the short term, and that long-term savings on advertising still depend on SEO succeeding. When evaluating a plan, consider the work involved, whether the website can turn visits into inquiries and orders, and the results it actually delivers. Ranking promises should not be treated as revenue guarantees.
Keyword marketing: perspectives from across the web
Does organic search always deliver a better return on investment than paid search?
There is no universal answer. In a poll cited by Semrush, about 49% of digital marketers considered organic search to have the highest return on investment among the main digital marketing channels for their websites, while 19% chose paid search. This reflects respondents' assessments of their own websites; it does not mean organic search is more cost-effective for every business, nor can these percentages alone predict the return on an individual campaign.
Will reaching the first page of search results increase orders?
Not necessarily. In a 2015 case shared on PTT, the poster reported helping a locksmith client reach the first page of search results, with customer calls increasing from one every few days to at least one a day. However, this is a self-reported individual case and cannot establish that the ranking was the sole cause of the increase in calls. The Da Vinci article also cautions that rankings and traffic do not guarantee sales; factors such as the website's persuasiveness, pricing, and checkout functionality may also affect results.
Is keyword marketing unaffordable for all small businesses?
Not necessarily. One business owner's experience cannot represent all small businesses. A PTT poster who ran an online auction business and had recently opened a shop said they found keyword marketing difficult to afford, but the post provides neither the quotes they compared nor their budget. Whether to invest depends on the business's own resources and the cost of the proposed plan. This experience cannot serve as a universal pricing benchmark.
References
- [討論] YAHOO全新搜尋平台搜便利www.ptt.cc — Discusses: Is keyword marketing unaffordable for all small businesses?
- 身為老闆的你,最應該知道SEO的10件事www.da-vinci.com.tw · 2025-01-23T22:25:25+08:00 — Discusses: Will reaching the first page of search results increase orders?
- [自介] 關鍵字行銷SEO達人www.ptt.cc — Discusses: Will reaching the first page of search results increase orders?
- Keyword Marketing: What It Is & How to Do Itwww.semrush.com · 2024-09-16T12:19:00Z — Discusses: Does organic search always deliver a better return on investment than paid search?


Join the discussion 0 comments
What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.