Skip to content
×

Why can optimizing for longer phrases also lead to rankings for shorter phrases?

A single page can rank for more than one search phrase. When a longer phrase contains a shorter one, and related wording appears in the page content and external links pointing to it, the page may appear in search results for both phrases. But ranking for the longer phrase does not guarantee rankings for the shorter one. The page may still be better suited to answering a complete, specific question.

The question a page targets is not the only query it can rank for

An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange points out that a page can rank for many search phrases. For example, even if a page primarily answers the full question “why does the sun shine,” its content will still contain shorter combinations of those words, so there is no need to treat every query as an unrelated target.

The answer suggests that wording in the page text and external links can explain why a page may rank for both longer and shorter phrases. The point is not to deliberately repeat short phrases, but that content written to answer a complete question may naturally include the words used in shorter queries. Still, including those words does not mean the page will rank for them; the answer offers no guarantee of ranking position or likelihood of success.

Longer phrases containing popular shorter terms may help readers find content through different queries

An article published on Neil Patel’s website in 2024 suggests a similar content approach: creating content around long-tail keywords that contain high-search-volume terms. It says these long-tail keywords typically face less competition and that the content may appear in search results for shorter phrases. This is the article’s recommendation, not a ranking rule published by a search platform.

  • Longer query: “how to find a digital marketing specialist in Manhattan”.
  • Potential shorter queries listed in the article: “digital marketing specialist” and “digital marketing”.

This example shows how readers may find the same piece of content through different queries, but it does not support a promise of rankings for shorter phrases. The article also recommends creating FAQ and problem-solving content because it is more likely to match individual searchers’ intent, rather than merely placing popular terms on a page.

A short phrase can face competition even if no one targets it directly

Another answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange questions the “1%” competition figure reported by the person asking the question. Even if few people directly target “why does the,” many websites may target complete questions that contain it. The text on those pages and in external links may also contain the shorter phrase. So a phrase is not necessarily easy to rank for just because few people make it their primary target.

It is also important to distinguish between potentially being found and meeting the searcher’s needs. “Why does the” is very broad on its own, and a page addressing one specific question may not satisfy people searching with that phrase. The answer cautions that visitors may not find what they want. Pursuing rankings for shorter phrases should therefore not come at the expense of clearly answering the complete question.

At Procrustes, our content service turns questions that genuinely matter to clients into articles, with ongoing planning, writing, and updates.

Ranking for longer and shorter search phrases: perspectives from across the web

Should very broad short phrases be the primary target?

A short phrase should not become the primary target simply because there is an opportunity to rank for it. Using “why does the” as an example, an answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange points out that such phrases cover a very broad range of needs. If a website lacks enough relevant content, visitors may not find the answers they want. A page addressing one specific question should focus first on answering it clearly, rather than assuming it can satisfy everyone searching with the shorter phrase.

If a tool shows very low competition for a short phrase, does that mean it is easy to rank for?

That figure alone is not enough to draw a conclusion. An answer on Webmasters Stack Exchange questions the “1%” competition figure in a particular case: even if few websites directly target the short phrase, many pages may target complete questions that contain it. Wording in their content and external links may also help those pages compete in search results for the shorter phrase. This criticism concerns that specific case; it does not imply that competition figures from all tools are unreliable.

Beyond including popular short phrases, what else should long-tail content consider?

Also consider whether the content addresses the specific needs expressed in the long-tail query. The article on Neil Patel’s website recommends FAQ or problem-solving content, such as a tutorial on cleaning a particular handbag, because this type of content is more likely to match an individual searcher’s intent. The article also suggests that long-tail keywords typically face less competition, but including popular shorter phrases does not guarantee that a page will appear in searches for those phrases.

References

  1. How to use low competition keywords with large search volume effectively?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Source used in the article above.
  2. How to use low competition keywords with large search volume effectively?webmasters.stackexchange.com — Discusses: Should very broad short phrases be the primary target?; If a tool shows very low competition for a short phrase, does that mean it is easy to rank for?
  3. Guide to Low Search Volume and Zero Search Keywordsneilpatel.com · 2024-07-12T19:00:00+00:00 — Discusses: Beyond including popular short phrases, what else should long-tail content consider?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp