Skip to content
×

Why might topic clusters fail to deliver results?

Topic clusters may fail to deliver results because the content does not meet users’ needs, there is no pillar page suited to the target search query, internal links are insufficient, or overlapping articles compete with one another. Pages may not have been crawled and indexed yet, making it too early to assess results. Before evaluating performance, clarify whether the goal is to get pages indexed, improve rankings for specific keywords, or guide readers to other pages. These are different goals. Publishing many articles does not, by itself, mean the strategy should be working.

Define success first: indexing, rankings, and navigation are different things

In a 2023 article, awoo author Chen Xitong described topic clusters as a way to produce content and organize a website systematically, rather than simply add links to articles. The functions outlined in the article suggest three areas to check:

  • If the goal is indexing: Have search engines discovered, crawled, and indexed the new pages?
  • If the goal is rankings: Are you trying to improve rankings for individual subtopics or for a more competitive core topic?
  • If the goal is navigation: Do the links guide readers to related content, rather than merely increasing the number of links?

These questions help clarify what to check; they do not guarantee results. The source does not provide a universal timeline for results or enough information to determine why a particular website’s strategy has failed.

More articles do not necessarily mean users’ needs have been met

The author emphasizes that both high-quality content and appropriate internal links are essential. If articles do not answer users’ questions, publishing more of them cannot make up for that shortcoming. Focus on the question each article answers, rather than simply counting the articles in a cluster.

At Procrustes, we turn the questions our clients genuinely care about into articles, with ongoing content planning, writing, and updates.

When assessing results, also consider whether pages have been crawled and indexed. The source notes that results can begin to emerge only after these steps. Drawing on consulting experience, the author also observes that websites lacking internal links may be crawled later. This is an observation based on experience, not a fixed rule for every website, and it does not mean that waiting longer will inevitably produce results.

Subtopics may rank even when a page answering the core question is missing

The source uses the “Nutritionist Ricky” website as an example, based on its content at the time. It already had articles about diet and exercise, but the author felt it still lacked a pillar page bringing both aspects together to answer “How do you build muscle and lose fat?” This was a case assessment from 2023. It does not mean the website still has the same gap today, nor does it prove that adding one article would secure a ranking.

Link placement should not simply follow a diagram either. The author advocates linking pillar and cluster pages to one another, with links between cluster pages added where relevant and appropriate. The article also cites criticism of HubSpot’s classic diagram: emphasizing only links from cluster pages to the pillar page can overlook relationships between subtopics. This does not mean every article should link to every other article.

Articles on very similar topics may compete with one another

For example, if “A guide to attractions in a particular destination” and “A guide to attractions for a day trip to that destination” differ only in the number of attractions listed, the source suggests they may compete within the site rather than answer distinct questions. Different clusters may also repeat the same comparison, such as “HydraFacial versus fractional laser treatment.” The author recommends covering the topic in detail on the page better positioned to do so, with brief summaries on other pages. Reviewing existing content before expanding coverage can help avoid duplicate content and duplicated effort.

Topic clusters: perspectives from across the web

Can cluster pages link only to pages within the same cluster?

No. Under the source’s narrow definition of topic clusters, a page can link to pages elsewhere on the same website if those links help users find what they need. What matters is whether the links fit the content and readers’ needs. There is no need to exclude other pages simply to maintain cluster boundaries.

Does a content hub without a pillar page necessarily mean a topic cluster has failed?

No. The absence of a pillar page alone does not establish failure. The source notes that some people use a broad definition that treats content hubs and topic clusters as essentially the same. Under the article’s narrower distinction, a topic cluster requires a pillar page, while a content hub does not. First clarify which definition is being used, then assess whether the structure serves the original purpose of organizing the content. The label alone does not demonstrate effectiveness.

Will consistently developing topic clusters establish authority and improve rankings?

There is no guarantee. In the 2023 article, the author suggests that consistently publishing high-quality content grounded in expertise and firsthand experience over the long term may attract backlinks. This approach can help demonstrate experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness on relevant topics and may indirectly support rankings. This is the author’s assessment of potential effects, not a claim that creating clusters automatically builds authority or improves rankings.

References

  1. 10 分鐘理解主題集群 Topic Cluster:SEO 經營策略的另一種視角www.awoo.ai · 2023-08-21T10:42:03+00:00 — Discusses: Can cluster pages link only to pages within the same cluster?; Does a content hub without a pillar page necessarily mean a topic cluster has failed?
Keep the conversation going

Join the discussion 0 comments

What are you working through? Share a question or experience and let’s find the next step.

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Share your thoughts

← Keep exploring
LET’S TALK

Start with your brand.

Tell me about your website and what you want to achieve.

WhatsApp tony@procrustes.info
Scan to chat on WhatsApp